WHITE PLAINS WESTCHESTER DAILY NEWS SERVICE VISITS SINCE 2000 A.D. 25TH YEARl REPORTING THE NEWS YOU NEED TO KNOW News Service Since 2000 A.D. 2026 WILL BE OUR 26TH YEAR OF COVERING WHITE PLAINS NEW YORK USA . John F. Bailey, Editor (914) 997-1607 wpcnr@aol.com Cell: 914-673-4054. News Politics Personalities Neighborhoods Schools Finance Real Estate Commentary Reviews Policy Correspondence Poetry Philosophy Photojournalism Arts. The WHITE PLAINS CITIZENETREPORTER. TELEVISION: "White Plains Week" News Roundup, 7:30 EDT FRI, 7 EDT MON & the incisive "People to Be Heard" Interview Program 8PM EDT THURS, 7 PM EDT SAT on FIOS CH 45 THROUGHOUT WESTCHESTER AND, ALTICE OPTIMUM WHITE PLAINS CH 1300 Fighting for Truth, Justice and the American Way. TOP 10 VISITORS FROM AROUND THE WORLD :1. USA. 2.BRAZIL3.VIET NAM 4. CHINA 5. JAPAN 6.UK. 7.CANADA. 8.INDIA. 9.AUSTRALIA 10.IRELAND 11.GERMANY 12..ARGENTINA 13.BANGLADESH 14.RUSSIA. 15.NEWZEALAND. 16. FRANCE. 17.MEXICO. 18.UKRAINE. 19.SOUTH AFVRICA. 20. IRAQ.
The abandoned Doral Arrowwood property as it appeared in 2020. Anderson Hill Road is in the lower left of the picture above.
WPCNR REALTY REALITY. Special to WPCNR From Cohen Brothers Realty Corporation. May 12, 2022:
Cohen Brothers Realty Corporation, a Manhattan-based national developer with major property interests in Westchester County and developer of 333 Westchester Avenue in White Plains, today announced a proposal for a dramatic redevelopment of the defunct Doral Arrowwood Hotel and Conference Center as a wellness-focused luxury boutique hotel and spa destination featuring multiple restaurants, celebrity-chef dining, extensive indoor and outdoor recreation facilities, and luxury housing.
The proposal calls for replacing the complex on Anderson Hill Road that closed in January 2020, with 146-room luxury boutique hotel, together with 36 apartments and 78 townhomes on the approximately 90-acre property, much of which would remain open space.
The concept will feature signature architecture and envisions two marquee destination restaurants, as well as a hotel restaurant, bars, lounges, fitness facilities, conference and meeting rooms, and ballrooms.
The existing hotel will be demolished, and the golf course will be reimagined as natural open space with a trail network.
The proposed project would create a new footprint that would define the aesthetic and environmental qualities of the site. It is expected to draw from the surrounding Westchester and southern Connecticut regions as well as New York City residents seeking a nearby luxury spa with signature amenities.
“We are very excited to be moving forward with a proposal that we believe is well-suited for the property, the adjacent community, the Village of Rye Brook and Westchester County,” said Charles S. Cohen, President/CEO of Cohen Brothers, who grew up in nearby Harrison. “This is a complete reimagination of an outdated use that is aligned with business and consumer trends of the 21st century.”
A formal proposal and application will be submitted to the Village of Rye Brook for consideration and discussion. (Editor’s Note: Asked when the project might begin, a spokesman said the company does not have firm plans to submit yet and start is “a way off.“
Cohen Brothers Realty Corporation is a private real estate development and management firm with more than 50 years of success in New York and across the country. The firm has built a national reputation for developing and redeveloping premier properties in prime locations and operating them impeccably, including 333 Westchester Avenue in White Plains. Once the headquarters of the General Foods Corp., Cohen Brothers acquired the 39-acre property and working with famed architect Philip Johnson transformed it into a multi-tenant office campus with lush gardens, tree-lined courtyards and first-class amenities.
COVID MINGLING CONTINUES: 553 MORE WESTCHESTER RESIDENTS REPORTED COVID POSITIVE TUESDAY AFTER WEEKEND.
COVIDSTOPPERS NOTEBOOK: Since April 18, in 3 weeks and 3 days Westchester County has grown covid cases to 3,120 ending Saturday, and it’s infection rates to over 10% on the same average number of tests 4,982 a day, with new positives Tuesday growing at 431 a Day. New York City all 5 Boroughs infections are averaging 3,816 a day, a rate of 28,000 a week. Nassau County and Suffolk had 1,814 new positives Tuesday. The Mid-Hudson region has doubled new positives in 3 weeks and 3 days.WPDH Radio in Poughkeepsie in Dutchess County reported that in Hyde Park, schools were closed the rest of the week because school bus companies had too many drivers infected with covid to drive enough school buses.
WPCNR THE COVID DAILY. From the New York State Covid Tracker. Observations and Analysis by John F. Bailey. May 12, 2022:
New Covid cases are running 431 cases a day since Sunday, rising in America’s richest county.
On Sunday, new cases of covid in Westchester County numbered 379 from a mere 3,492 PCR Tests Saturday. The PCR test results are the only test results being reported by the New York State Department of Health
Look what happened on Monday and Tuesday of this week the last days results were reported:
On Sunday reporting, 5,578 PCR tests reported administered Saturday found 497 infections Saturday (9.1%) the day before. If 5,000 came in to test Sunday instead of 3,492 being tested producing 342 you might have gotten 550 new positives. If 10,000 were tested Sunday, you might have gotten 1,000 positives.
This is what I call the hidden spread: persons not testing, asymptomatic like Governor Hochul, or anyone for that matter and resuming back to normal activities, when Westchester is not back to normal.
If the proportion of positives Saturday 497 positive on 5,578 tests, growing 10% of those test was the same growing at 9% you could conceivably have grown to 1,100 positives on Sunday — if 10,000 had been tested Sunday.
On Monday, 2,926 persons were tested. That produced 363 positives, 13.4%. The 2,926 tested Monday is 1/3 of 10,000. So if 10,000 tested Monday,with the same 13% positive portion as appeared Monday, you might have found 1,137 new persons positive with covid.
Now here’s the twist:
Persons numbering 553 were reported being positive in Westchester Tuesday on 5,406 tests.
On Monday, 2,926 were tested and 363 were found positive. 2,926 IS 54% of 5,406 tests. If you double the 363 positives (that tested positive Sunday, but were reported Monday), you get 726, more than the 553 .
But this serendipitous example I just found demonstrates the ominous proportional “hidden” growth on this most recent example demonstrates how high numbers in low testing of positives, I believe means many more infections and misery in the weeks ahead.
Is this really a hidden spread? You have over 10% testing positive on 5,000 tests that’s 500 a day, 3500 a week next week.
There are no plans to do anything about this. Vaccines are down. Testing is available, but tests are the same average per day they have been since February 1.
Monday and Tuesday showed results of possible infection of persons worried enough to get tested Sunday, 363 tested positive Monday, and yesterday, 553 tested positive of 5,406 taking the PCR test.
Using the proportional projection. If you test more you will get more cases than Westchester can handle very shortly.
This will happen if the new positives on low quantities continue at the high infection rates the last 17 days.
The low number of tests appear to be because people can only get the most effective PCR tests at authorized locations like the Westchester County Center, the Yonkers Armory, and the Westchester County Department of Health in White Plains on Court Street and popup locations. Those locations and times are available on the www.westchestergov.com website. The PCR tests are also used by public schools in the county, which distributes the preferred tests to schools requesting them.
As most people should know there are at-home tests, but only PCR test results are reported by the state as the official new daily case counts since April 4.
Let’s look back:
The number of tests being administered per day in 8 weeks when new positive covid cases in Westchester was in decline from February 1 to April 4 was 4,992 in Westchester County,.
Infections had declined throughout February to an average 492 a week with a daily infection rate of 2%.
In March, the covid virus continued in decline two weeks were up but went down the next week The last week in March the virus came back, went up to 1,095 infections up 27%–the first bellwether Westchester was bringing covid back big time.
Beginning the first week in April the County has increased infections steadily for 6 weeks, rising from 1,095 cases the last week in March to 1,895; 2,027; 2,156 the next week; then 2,459 then last week growing to 3,120 new infections. The Fifth Wave has begun.
The average number of tests per day during the April-May Covid surge was 4,981. There has been no wide swings in tests administered since February 1.
Meanwhile, since April 24, 2 weeks and 3 days ago, the infection rate has gone from 7% infected test takers the week of April 24 to 30; to 8.4% May 1 to 7.
The Westchester infection rate has exploded on slightly higher testing to 11.4% on 3,941 tests in just 3 days.
This big switch, as far as WPCNR makes out is the main reason there are lower numbers of tests:
It’s hard to get the PCR test it is not on every corner. Another reason could be fear of being found positive and having to quarantine or not socialize or miss school, or not go to work.
As WPCNR has pointed out previously, the larger numbers testing positive on lower Covid test universes indicate more people in the Westchester and metropolitan area in general are catching and spreading the Covid virus, no matter what the variant variety they get – and spreading it faster—seeing and infecting too many people. It is behavior that is causing yet again, another wave.
If 10,000 had tested Monday in Westchester, you would have had the 1,000 positives. I cannot get my mind around that.
This is the hidden spread not being reported.
With not enough persons coming in for the reliable PCR tests at county facilities, you just are not getting a complete picture of the penetration of the spread every hour and its disruptive potential.
You are on your own. Covid is really out there. The unlucky positives the last three days prove that.
NUMBER OF INFECTIONS LAST WEEK PARALLEL TO THE 2,,791 FOR WEEK OF DEC 6-11 THAT CREATED 77,828 COVID CASES IN JANUARY.
WPCNR COVID DAILY. From the NYS COVID TRACKER. Observations & Analysis by John F. Bailey. May 9, 2022:
Westchester County experienced its sixth straight week of rising infections when Friday’s new covid infections hit 550 in the county followed by 497 new persons testing positive Saturday.
For the record, there were 3,120 new persons showing positive for covid May 1 to 7, two weeks after schools reopened after spring break.
HOVER COVER AND CLICK ON WHITE ARROW TO FOLLOW THE MAY 1 TO 7 COVID DAY BY DAY LAST WEEK FROM THE WPCNR COVID LOGBOOK. INFECTION RATE AVERAGED 9% IN WESTCHESTER LAST WEEK ON LOW 5,000 TO 6,000 A DAY TESTING.
Based on the 2,156 infections two weeks between Jan. 16 to 23 they spread the disease in two weeks to 3,120 people. Dividing 3,120 infections last week by 2,156 computes a “Spread Rate” of each infected person of 2,156 two weeks ago spread the disease to 1.54 persons.
Multiply 3,120 by 1.54 and you see the county faces a minimum of 4,804 persons to 6,000 depending if a 1 to .54 persons spread rate holds. This of course does not count the untold thousands who may have covid in their breath or in their nostrils and do not have symptoms of the disease so are not testing themselves.
Governor Kathy Hochul just Sunday announced she had tested positive for covid, but was asymptomatic (not suffering symptoms).
WPCNR believes without any state statistics I know of the number of persons tested positive but were asymptomatics could BE the factor in escalating the disease new infection spread for six consecutive weeks.
Asymptimatic positives are a stat that has to be broken down on these small number of positive tests.
It is imperative to see if — of the fully vaccinated, the partially vaccinated and the non vaccinated — patients testing positive—whether a majority are asymptomatic, not showing symptoms.
Asymptomatics could accelerate the spread, particularly if not masking and continuing to mingle closely at large gatherings in schools, venues, restaurants, political town halls, campaign functions.
The infection rate average for week May 1 to 7 is: 8.5% of 35,449 tested, 3,120 persons. The average new cases per day were 445 in Westchester County.
A matter of concern if I was a politician or in the Department of Health is the eerie parallel to the time when infections started to rise in September, October increasing incrementally, building larger every day and multiplying rapidly three weeks after Thanksgiving climbing to 280 a day, 2,791 positives the week of December 11 take a look:
HOVER, COVER AND CLICK THE WHITE ARROW TO FOLLOW The Parallel Spread: December 6 to 11, 2022, that set the stage for 11,450 new Covid Cases by December 25. Notice how the numbers compare with last week’s break through to 3,123 infections.
On it climbed, the 2,791 doubled to 5,397 in the week of December 18.
The covids spread exponentially touching off a shocking doubling of new infections on the week before Christmas, ending December 25, the biggest wave of Covid the 4th Wave from December through January. On December 25 when 11,450 new infections were reported.
In the next three weeks from Christmas to New Years, and the first two weeks of January, The Fourth Wave exploded to 51,000 the first two weeks in January and went down thanks to the vaccinations rapidly stopping it the last two weeks through January to 3,423 on January 29 of this year.
Now Westchester has sadly, in a rush to “get back to normal” has gotten back to a 5th Wave of Covid about to begin, if you look at the past 6 weeks. The disease is spreading again.
THE SATURDAY MAY 7 COVIDSTOPPERS NOTEBOOK
This is not pretty all around the metropolitan area . WESTCHESTER averaged over 500 new infections for four straight days, averaged 445 new infections a day for the week All last week Orange County and Rockland accelerate new numbers of persons testing positive. Dutchess and Ulster were positively up from previous levels..
The Mid- Hudson region recorded averaged over 1,015 infections a day the 7 days last week, a total of 7,110 infections a week. This means perhaps a doubling of infections in the region in two weeks (14,000 or more).
The Long Island situation is spreading new infections at a steady average of 900 cases in Nassau County and 800 for Suffolk County.
New York City (all 5 boroughs reporting) recorded 25,883 New covid positives last week. The 5 boroughs compined averaged 3,697 new covid positives a day. Given the 1.5 person spread rate over 2 weeks that may double in 2 weeks to 39,859.
The pattern is not good.
But the lack of statistics from the state on who is getting covid, how sick are they getting, and are they staying sick longer has to start being known.
Wishing and hoping do not make covid go away. You have to not get get it.
The pattern of testing is lower testing on the first, second and third days of the week then it goes up sharply as people get symptoms and go in and get tested which says to me the disease is a lot more infectious and citizens are not taking precautions.
This just in: the New York State Covid Tracker Sunday Report of Positives in Westchester. Yesterday, May 8 had 379 Test positive of 3,492 tested. The 379 represents 10.2%, the highest infection percentage in 10 weeks and up in number from last Sunday. If you tested 10,476 you might very well have had 1,137 more positives, considering that the percentage rate would stay the same. Hopefully this first day out of the chute this week will decline and more will come in to test and show less positives.
THE RECREATED RECORDING STUDIO ON STAGE AT MILLION DOLLAR QUARTET AWAITING THE LIVING LEGENDS Photo by WPCNRJERRY LEE (TREVOR DORNER), CARL PERKINS (NATHAN BURKE), MIKE POTTER AS THE MAN IN BLACK JOHNNY CASH, AND THE KING, JACOB BARTON IS ELVIS ON THE JAM OF ALL-TIME. Sean CaseyFlanagan is the Producer Sam Phillips in the booth.(Performance Photos, Courtesy, Westchester Theatre by Jason Niedel)
WESTCHESTER THEATRE DEBUT:THE BIG BEAT BLASTS INTO CHAPPAQUA PERFORMING ARTS CENTER.
THE ROCK JAM SESSION THAT NEVER ENDS
WPCNR STAGE DOOR. THIRD ROW CENTER Theatrical Review By John F. Bailey. May 8, 2022:
It’s rock and roll raw.
Their guitars twang.
They move.
They sing the songs that live and make you feel alive and you are forever young.
You move—
Involuntarily, you tap your foot to the throb of the drums in your blood – the big beat really has its hold on you.
The immortals are back rasping, howling, growling raw excitement that gets to you like no other, sassed up with the zing, zip, rip rock of gladiator guitars!
The ethereal experience starts right from the first da da da da da da da of Blue Suede Shoes!
Nathan Burke’s Carl Perkins brings back one night that lives forever. The man who introduced rock and roll records, Sam Phillips, the mn who knew hits when he heard one recognized the infusion of joy in the rock and roll sound and rocked and rolled America forever by recording Elvis Presley on his studio in a chicken coop in Memphis
“MR. BLUE SUEDE SHOES” NATHAN BURKE (FOREGROUND) IS CARL PERKINS NAILING EVERY GUITAR CLASSIC RIFF CRISP, CLEAN, UNFORGETTABLE. JASON BARTON IS ELVIS SINGING THE WAY YOU REMEMBER HIM AND MIKE POTTER’S DEEP TENNESSEE DRAWL SAYS “HE’S JOHNNY CASH”
The original Fab Four get the “aging-up” jump, twist and jive in the red carpet posh-seated jury of the Chappaqua Performing Arts Center. The young get that itchy, twitchy feelin’ wondering what’s this music all about that makes me want to sing and shout.
The greatest hits from the Million Dollar Quartet of sullen, chilling cool and unleashed machismo of Jacob Barton as Elvis.
‘THE KILLER’ JERRY LEE LEWIS (TREVOR DORNER) LEAPS FROM THE POUNDED PIANO A SIGNATURE MOVE, TAYLOR KRAFT AS DYANNE GETS INTO THE ROCK N ROLL MAYHEM. BASSMAN BEN SHEPARD LAYS DOWN SOUL-JIVIN’ BASS AND MIKE LUCCHETTI POUNDS OUT THE ROCK BEAT NONSTOP THAT SHAKES YOUR BONES! “THE SUIT” SAM PHILLIPS ON THE SUN LABEL KNOWS HE HAS HIT AFTER HIT — MAYBE! YOU BET! THESE ARE THE HITS THAT KEEP ON PLAYING YOU SING ALONG TOO!
Trevor Dorner’s Arkansas drawlin’ piano pounding makes the 88 black and white keys shake with an overthe topJerry Lee Lewis.
Mike Potter’s slow-talkin deep haunting Johnny Cash the Man in Black
Nathan Burke’s Carl Perkins, the man in the Blue Suede Shoes, forever doomed to backup when Elvis stole his hit, but in this show he is the twanging riffmaster of the electric guitar. Wait until you hear his fingers and pick run out a flawless up-and-down-in-and-out master riffing of the greatest guitar solo of all-time on Houndog.
Million Dollar Quartet, The Gershwin Entertainment Production brought in by Bill Stutler, former Co-Producer of Westchester Broadway Theatre with Bob Funking the last 46 years, is tuning up for its national tour this summer.
MDQ gives the new Westchester Theatre a charismatic start bringing back and introducing the professional quality productions Westchester audiences have loved on 46 years . No dinner, just come to hear the music that’s all.
MDQ is not just a juke box musical, it looks back how Sam Phillips of Sun Recordstook the black sound of rhythm and blues and brought it to the repressed 1950s. Phillips freed a generation that changed the country and the world through its music releasing a young America to be themselves, a music that responded to their feelings, concerns, and anxieties and wrote about them perfectly.
This is the inside baseball of the recording business. It recreates a typical recording session where rivals and competitors try and one-up each other with riffs and get into playing different takes on their songs, styles and riffs while Mr. Phillips, played by Sean Casey Flanagan, is hilariously bombastic and promoty as the Sun Records operator. The audience is given an appreciation of the big business rock and roll records were about to become as old time recording giants vied to sign up Johnny Cash, after signing away Elvis Presley away from Sun Records.
The Phillips-released recording of Mystery Train first played on WERE in Cleveland in 1955 by the deejay Bob Randle, was Elvis Presley’s first hit that caused a sensation among the teenage girls of Cleveland when Randle played it.
You watch the session unfold, punctuated by the rivalries and the respect the four soon-to-be-legends had for each other’s talents.
First to come in is Jerry Lee Lewis who wants Mr. Phillips who’s looking for piano backup, to sign him to a contract, joined by Carl Perkins, who resents when Jerry tries to play piano to his Blue Suede Shoes session.
MDQ is a Tony Award Winner on Broadway. Its flawless telling and showing the interpersonal squabbles erupting and subsiding as song after song is performed, 23 in all, you get the magic. You realize the bond that these musical competitors who have made it, Cash and Presley and two who have not—show the anxieties of the entertainment business, put the pull it has on the performer. They love it.
The one thing that unites all four is they love to perform and play for the people. This wonderful bond of artist and audience is given realife credence and explains why artists are loved by their audiences.
They perform for you.
The mannerisms of Elvis Presley’s girl friend of the moment demo the fascination young women had for Elvis. Taylor Kraft as Dyanne is surly, tough, streetwise and has fondness “The King.”
Kraft credibly shows the fascination for the music she is hearing in her body language. His girl of the moment played by Taylor Kraft, an expert in the role, having played in MDQ productions for six years and now is joining her first national tour. She is not a spare part, but subtlely shows what made rock and roll music from these four legends the idle of teenage girls and women, so much that boys and men back in the day wanted to be like them. Dress like them, style their hair in the pompadour.
The actors perform with the spirits of these performers apparently taken over their actors’ bodies. The actors are all veterans in the roles—a hallmark of Westchester Broadway Theatre tradition now born again at Chappaqua Performing Arts Center.
The effect of the show for the audience is that of being guests in a recording studio “behind the glass” watching the very private chemistry between artists in a spectacle that has taken them over and changed their lives forever. Because it did. The audience in Saturday’s matinee were transported as the hits just kept on coming.
Jerry Lee’s Trevor Dorner sounded and played the old broken down piano like Jerry Lee. He captured Mr. Lewis raw sexual energy, ran the keys, and yes, played the piano with his feet.
Mike Potter, inhabited by the spirit of Johnny Cash sounded uncannily like Johnny, looked like him, he sounded spot-on on Folsom Prison Blues, Walk the Line, Sixteen Tons and of course, I Walk The Line. He even says, “Hello, I’m Johnny Cash,” just so right—and looks like him too, even to folding a 100 dollar bill under his guitar strings.
The show plays through May 22.
Bill Stutler, the impresario of Westchester Theatre greeted the matinee crowd at the doors of the theater.
When the emcee welcomed folks on stage, an old WBT tradition, mentioning Westchester Broadway, most of the audience clapped in appreciation. Waiting for the original hits and personalities who made them In a masterful guitar solo, startling drums by the tireless master of the BEAT, Mike Lucchetti and the man the big bass that throbbed, bobbed and laid tireless driving rhythm on and on, the full 2 hours nonstop hits, quips, stories, flares and beat-enthused energy, always impatient for the next great song.
They did not want to stop.
They played encores—Great Balls of Fire, Hound Dog, Ghost Riders in the Sky (right on by Mr. Potter’s Johnny Cash echoing voice) See You Later Alligator, and Whole Lotta Shakin’ Going On, and invited the audience to dance and it went on and on.
Oh what a night!
Mom will love it if she used to rock and roll.
Contact the Westchester Theatre at (866) 806-5777 or go online for tickets plays through May 22 at www.TheWestchesterTheatre.com.
CLICK THE WHITE ARROW TO THE LEFT ABOVE TO VIEW LATEST WHITE PLAINS WEEK WITH JOHN BAILEY THE WHITE PLAINS CITIZENETREPORTER FOR 22 YEARS SINCE 2000 A.D.
NEW YORK STATE COVID TRACKER REPORTING THERE WERE 550 NEW PERSONS TESTING POSITIVE FOR COVID IN 5,650 TESTS ADMINISTERED FRIDAY, PUSHING THE LAST 6 DAYS TOTAL NEW CASES TO 2,623 BEFORE TODAY’S COVID TESTS ARE REPORTED. THE 2,623 MARKS THE SIXTH CONSECUTIVE WEEK COVID NEW POSITIVES HAVE INCREASED IN THE COUNTY.
SHOULD WESTCHESTER POSITIVES COME IN AT 400 CASES TODAY SATURDAY, WHICH WILL BE REPORTED SUNDAY, IT WOULD PUSH WESTCHESTER TO OVER 3,000 NEW INFECTIONS THIS WEEK, MAY 1 TO 7
THE LAST TIME WESTCHESTER RECORDED OVER 3,000 NEW POSITIVES FOR COVID IN ONE WEEK WAS THE LAST WEEK IN JANUARY 14 WEEKS AGO.THE NEW CASES HAVE BEEN INCREASING FOR 6 WEEKS.
THE REST OF THE MID-HUDSON REGION CONTINUES TO GROW IN INFECTIONS. SO DO NASSAU AND SUFFOLK COUNTIES WHICH TOGETHER FOUND 1,732 NEW POSITIVES IN 15,181 TESTS, A POSITIVE RATE OF 11%.
NEW YORK CITY REPORTED THROUGH ALL 5 BOROUGHS 3,373 NEW CASES. THURSDAY NYC REPORTED 7.264 PERSONS NEWLY TESTED POSITIVE
WPCNR VIEW FROM THE UPPER DECK. By “Bull Allen” . May 8, 2022:
It was 65 years ago when it happened.
It can happen to any of us any time in our lives.
I heard it happen to Herb Score.
On the radio with Mel Allen doing the broadcast from Cleveland on WINS 1010.
It was the first inning at Municipal Stadium in Cleveland and the best lefthander in the American League at the time, 1955 Rookie of the Year,1956 strikeout leader, 20 game winner was on the mound for “The Tribe.”
There were 18,000 fans in the old double-decked Wigwam on the lake built the year Herb Score was born.
Tom Sturdivant was pitching for the Yankees, another rookie phenom.
The crowd came to see a pitching duel.
What they saw they would never forget.
“The Tribe,” for years a class contending team in the American League, perennial challengers to the 1950s New York Yankees was finally poised to overtake the dominance of the Bronx Bombers, the 1956 World Champions.
The Tribe had Score and Lemon and Wynn and Garcia their four starters, and power hitter Rocky Colavito, Bobby Avila, Roger Maris, Gene Woodling, Al Smith, Vic Wertz in the lineup. Score was the new Tribe, the hope of the fans.
I had his baseball card.
Score in his big long stride over-the-top southpaw delivery was a strikeout King at only 23 years of age.
He retired the first batter, Hank Bauer in the Lake Erie twilight
Then Gil McDougald, Yankee shortstop, second batter stood in the batter’s box.
I was 12 years old, and Mel Allen was on the play-by-play, describing in his tense mellow style that sounded like this what I remember he said or would have voiced,
“Score into the windup down comes the left arm and the pitch….McDougald swings a line drive a bullet…it hits Score ….bounds to Smith at third. Score is down, he’s hurt. McDougald is stopped, walking to the mound Smith at third throws to first for the out Score is curled up motionless….(the crowd was hushed in silence).
I turned the radio off. I was in tears.
I think of this sobering incident every year on May 7. It happened 65 years ago tonight.
Herb Score’s Baseball Encyclopedia Entry.
Herb Score the strikeout leader in his rookie year 1955 with 245 strikeouts and 16 win, 10 losses 11 complete games in his first year in the real big leagues. Amazing debut. Talk of the league. He filled Muncipal Stadium (Cleveland Stadium) every time he pitched.
Herb Score held the Major league record for most strikeouts by a rookie pitcher, 245 before Dwight Gooden of the Mets broke it 1984 with 276 (at the age of 19).
Then in 1956, Score the strickeout leader struck out more than 245, with 263 K’s in his second season, 1956, winning 20 games and losing nine, with Hall of Fame stuff. Big Train fastball and sweeping curve.
At 6 foot 2 inches and 185 pounds he was the second of the bigger, stronger pitchers (the other was Big Newk, Don Newcombe) to come in the 1960s when pitching by taller, “power” pitchers Don Drysdale, Sandy Koufax, Denny McLain, Frank Lary, Bob Gibson, Steve Carlton, began to dominate the hitters with dominating stuff, and quite frankly, intimidation. Finesse pitchers like Whitey Ford and Billy Pierce began to become less effective and pitched lesser innings giving way to the birth of the closer. But that is another story.
They did not televise Yankee roadgames in those days. There is no televised replay of this incident that I could locate to show this incident.
Score was never quite the same, but Mr. Score pitched for the Indians through 1959, but was not as effective. Herb said it was not the eye-injury that affected his pitching, but rather his arm experienced troubles. He said, “I just wasn’t pitching as well.”
Score was a lesson for us fans of the game at the time.
Whenever he pitched in subsequent years, and I saw his name as starting pitcher, I always checked on the box score of his game. I admired him trying to comeback. I rooted for him. Every fan did. Like we rooted for Tony Conigliaro struck in the eye by a pitch.
When he did retire just six years later, he became an Indians broadcaster for decades. The Voice of the Indians.
The fans loved Herb Score. He never complained or looked back and cursed his luck. He said you cannot look back.
He represents more than any other ballplayer how fleeting is success, how fragile happiness is, how a misstep, an accident, a false word, a loss of temper, a loss of wariness and being careful or doing something stupid, can turn around your life, your career, in an instant.
Waite Hoyt the old Yankee pitcher of the 1920s said “I’d rather be lucky than good.”
Score was a great pitcher, a natural.
But he was not lucky.
He was not bitter.
He had courage.
An athlete to remember.
He was from Rosedale, Queens. He was no stranger to illness and misfortune when he was a child. He made to the major leagues despite a serious auto accident injuring his legs, and overcoming illnesses. A real New Yorker, son of a New York City policeman.
The legacy of Herb Score is to keep looking to the future.
Forget about the past and keep moving on as best you can.
Even when a line drive shatters your dreams, you can still make them come true and do the best with what you have.