Hits: 0
WPCNR SCHOOL DAYS. By John F. Bailey, March 8, 2007 UPDATED WITH CURRENT INFLATION RATES: The Board of Education presented their almost-final budget of $173.9 Million for 2007-2008 to the last meeting of the Annual Budget Committee Wednesday evening, reporting that thanks to a “hefty increase” in revenue from PILOTs (Up $1.6 Million), and a savings of $365,000 in retirement and federal programs they were able to cut the year to year budget increase to 4.82% — still more than double the 2% inflation from Jan 2006 to January 2007, current inflation as of January 2007 is 2.75%) and the lowest year to year budget hike since 1998-99 (when the budget was $79 Million and went up 3.43%).
The tax increase, despite the cuts will be 8.35% more than last year’s 8.1% when the budget increase was 7.1%.
The cut has not prevented the tax rate increase from going to 8.35% compared to this budget year rate of 8.12%. This means if your house assessable value is $18,500 you pay $8,895 in school taxes in 2007-2008. Superintendent of Schools Timothy Connors said the administration would be looking to cut more before the public hearing on the budget March 19. The Board is scheduled to adopt the budget March 26.
The Band Must Look Good.
The latest budget is sitting on $173.9 Million, down from the $174.5 Million on the table one week ago.
Fred Seiler, background, and Superintendent of Schools Tim Connors present the bottom line: a 4.82% cut.
The reason it has not declined more is that the Board has included $180,000 to renovate the Church Street School playground and $96,000 for new White Plains High School Band Uniforms while devoting the 2006-2007 $2 Million surplus to paying the $2.8 Million settlement with Travelers Guaranty and Surety Company revealed by WPCNR last week.
LESLEY TOMPKINS and a contingent from the White Plains High School Band “lobbied” the ABC Committee with a rendition of EYE OF THE TIGER to make a pitch for new uniforms. It worked!
The Superintendent and the Assistant Superintendent for Business Fred Seiler blamed the uptick in taxes on the decline in the assessment roll for the fifth year in succession, showing a chart documenting the decline from $450 Million in 1988-89 to $292 Million in 2007-2008.
The Superintendent was called on by several members of the committee to involve the city to stop the assessment drain. The Superintendent said they had tried, that it was up to members of the public to put pressure on city and state representatives to address the problem.
A few Explanations
Seiler explained in response to previous ABC Committee questions that New Rochelle (with a higher budget) has a lower cost per student than White Plains because it has 4,000 more students, its employees pay more their share of health insurance; more elementary class size (23 compared to White Plains’ 20 students per class), and lower teachers’ salaries.
Seiler said that the district currently pays health insurance for 700 retired employees at a cost of $4.8 Million. At the close of the meeting, two members of the committee suggested the district negotiate hard for a more equitable health plan for the district teachers and employees where the employees paid more of the cost. Connors said the Teachers Union has asked to work with the district to examine the cost benefits of other health plans.
A New Playground
Pictures were shown of the Church Street playground demonstrating how the concrete has deteriorated, and a parent and an employee of the school explained how the equipment was dangerous and antiquated and that the school had no field for the children to play on. (However, this reporter recalls that when his daughter attended Church Street School, Gardella Park was used by the school. Apparently the school no longer uses those facilities, but we will check as to why.)
One parent protested that the district should work with the city to find funding to pay for the $180,000 cost to improve the playground, rather than pay the entire cost itself in a tough budget year. Another parent, said “we shouldn’t have to pay for all of it because we missed the city’s capital project deadline.” In the end, in the face of little opposition, the district opted apparently to keep the playground in as well as pay for all the band uniforms and new band instruments this year, since both those items were already included in the slides shown on the screen.
Capital Project Impacts Next Year
Seiler gave a preview of the impact the Capital Project would have on 2008-2009 budget, saying it would increase the budget $1.8 Million for the debt service, increasing the tax rate 1%. No one asked why the Church Street playground could not be included in the Church Street school renovations called for in the Capital Project.
Next Seiler took up the certiorari effects, but gave no long term view of what certiorari impacts were coming down the pike. The district has already agreed with the city to pay current certiorari settlements on an installment basis over the next three years. Marc Pollitzer the perpetual activist hammered the district on the need to get the city to pay attention to the certiorari problem. “The answer is not in this room,” Pollitzer said, “The answer is in City Hall.”
Conners said to expect more certioraris in the future: “The train keeps going and each year the assessments keep going down.”
Donna McLaughlin of the School Board defended the city, saying it was not just the city to blame, but the equalization rate. At that point Connors moved the conversation on to the next topic, cutting off any rebuttal. Connors said, “We need you (the people) to help us take care of that. You must talk to your representatives and tell them what you think.”
Assemblyman Adam Bradley introduced a bill to equalize the rates at which commercial and residential properties are assessed last year, but it has never gotten out of committee in the legislature. WPCNR will check on how that bill is doing shortly.
After going over expenditures, state aid and revenues, Seiler saved the bad news until last:
The $2.8 high school overrun settlement combined with the sickening freefall in the assessment roll, mean Mr. and Mrs. White Plains will face a 8.35% school tax increase in a budget only slightly ahead of the year-to-year inflation rate.
At the close of the meeting, the Superintendent asked each member of the Committee to tell what they felt about the budget. Not all spoke, but here is a sampling of attitudes:
“Talk with the city and fight some of their certs.”
“Prudent budget.”
“Work on Health Costs.”
“I’d vote against it (the budget).”
“Work with other districts to consolidate costs.”
“Really good (budget).”
“Be more critical of what’s going in (budget).”
“Something has to change.”
“The problem is on Main Street.”
“We had last year’s assessor doubletalk us (on assessments and PILOTS). We need to talk to the new (acting) assessor (Lloyd Tash) because what he does gets reflected in the tax rate.”
“We need to talk to the assessor about the commercial tax rate and what he has to say.”
Class Notes
Superintendent Connors told WPCNR he has not formed the Action Plan Committees yet to begin implementing the Strategic Objectives of the new District Strategic Plan. He hoped to finalize some of them Thursday…
Charlie Norris, an active member of the high school PTA announced to WPCNR he was running for one of the two seats on the Board of Education.
Michelle Tratoros, President of the School Board, whose term is expiring told WPCNR she has not made up her mind whether to run for reelection
The $1.6 Million increase in PILOTS comes from the coming on stream of Kensico Terrace (Bill Brown’s affordable housing senior apartments), and 1133 Westchester Avenue.