Hits: 0
WPCNR Common Council Chronicle-Examiner. By John F. Bailey. June 8, 2004: In an untidy exchange of commentaries between Rita Malmud and Mayor Joseph Delfino that reignited longtime New York Presbyterian opponents to allege the city was paying for legal advice to pave the way for commercially rezoning the North end of the NYPH property in the heart of White Plains, the council voted 6-1 to pay the environmental lawyer, Michael Gerrard $50,000 to conduct a zoning study of NYPH land.
The expenditure was separated out by Councilperson Rita Malmud from the routine Community Development fund appropriations, so the issue of hiring Gerard could be discussed on the council floor. Mayor Delfino began the procedure by saying how well “informed” the council was. However, the council did not remember what the $50,000 expenditure was for. Malmud said she objected to hiring Gerard to conduct the study because she was unhappy with the way he represented the city on past matters. Just last week in a work session, Commissioner of Planning Susan Habel noted that Community Development funding grants had been cut by $109.000 over the last two years.
Alan Teck, Barbara Benjamin, and Marc Pollitzer all surfaced after many months of absence to protest the expenditure. Teck was cut short in his remarks by Mayor Delfino who said his remarks were not relevant to the topic, causing Teck to change direction and encourage the city to persuade the New York Presbyterian Hospital to consider purchasing the closed St. Agnes Hospital buildings that are being put up for auction by the New York State Dormitory Authority through a Request for Proposals process.
Teck said the hospital should consider purchasing that property for “50 cents on the dollar” (the property according to the Westchester County Business Journal has an outstanding debt of $36 Million), and use that for their planned research facilities. Mayor Delfino flatly, speaking for the Hospital, said, “I can tell you they are not interested.”
Benjamin said that a park consultant should be hired, not a zoning lawyer. Marc Pollitzer, long New York Presbyterian Hospital nemesis, echoed Teck’s sentiments.
Commissioner of Planning Susan Habel was called in to explain. Habel said Gerrard was being hired because of concerns the city had that rezoning a portion of the NYPH land was “spot zoning,” and that the city simply wished to explore the implications for the municipality legally if they were to explore rezoning commercial medical in return for leasing park land. She said Gerard would not be making any recommendations on park design or usage.
After the “assurance” from the Commissioner, the Council voted 6-1 to approve the hiring of Gerrard’s law firm to execute the study.









