Hits: 0
WPCNR COMMON COUNCIL-CHRONICLE EXAMINER. By John F. Bailey. August 4, 2009: After a lengthy explanation of the status of the Gedney Way city dump and where it stood from the Commissioner of Public Works, Joseph Nicoletti Monday night, the Council approved expenditure of $250,000 to prepare a preliminary closing plan for the dump for submission to the Department of Environmental Conservation in three months. Rita Malmud explained to the public on television the Council was only approving $250,000 in bonding at this time.

Joseph Nicoletti, Commissioner of Public Works, addressing the Common Council on the State of the Gedney Dump Monday night.

The Common Council (with Councilman Thomas Roach taking the lead above) tabled until August 27 the approval of Lamb and Barnosky as Labor Counsel for the city during the upcoming binding arbitration with the Fire Fighters union that is expected to set the tone for the next round of labor increases. The tabling came at the request of Councilman Thomas Roach who said he wanted to interview the firm before approval. He did not explain in detail what he wanted to ask the firm.
The Counsel kept open two hearings on the White Plains Hospital Medical Center 5 year site plan window (the first ever such favor to a developer, giving the hospital five years to start the project), with no citizens from the public commenting.
The hearing on the North Street Community increase in the assisted living to condominium units ratio at the former
Certioraris in the amount of $158,000 were approved, which also lowered the assessment roll $196,000.
A sum of $222,500 turned over from the Affordable Housing Fund to the White Plains Housing Authority for use in investing funds to secure a Housing and Urban Development $1.7 Million grant to upgrade energy efficiency at Schuyler DeKalb housing.
However, no member of the Council asked Commissioner Nicoletti during 45 minutes of testimony for an estimate of how much the DEC order to close and cap the Gedney Dump would cost the city. Mr. Nicoletti confirmed to WPCNR after the meeting that in addition to the initial $250,000, the capping of thedump could cost about $8 Million to $10 Million “on the upside in today’s dollars.”
Despite Ms. Malmud’s assurances that the city was only investing $250,000 at this time, Nicoletti explained to the council on television that the city has to close and cap the dump and there was no choice in the matter, since the city had signed a consent order to do so in 2005.

Commissioner of Public Works, Joseph Nicoletti, on the State of the Dump Monday night

Asked by this reporter , why Mr. Roach did not ask Mr. Nicoletti how much possible millions the city was going to have to spend on the Gedney dump cleanup during the televised hearing, Councilman Roach (who asked a number of questions about dump acitvity, on television montior above), said it is “too early.”
Asked for an estimate what he thought it would cost, Mr. Roach said “It’s not going to be cheap, that’s for sure.” To see the Common Council Nicoletti “State of the Dump Address,” tune to White Plains Government Access Channel 75 Wednesday evening.
Nicoletti told the televised meeting the DEC has in the past (in the mid-90s) decided the TCE contamination remaining in the dump at this time did not have to be physically removed by digging it out.
Containment the Answer
Nicoletti said that an iron containment enclosure could be used to hasten the breakdown on the TCE containment. He did not in over 45 minutes of addressing the council, say what capping the dump might consist of, or how much it would cost. He also assured the public the city has been monitoring the pollution and contamination in the dump for the last 23 years under the supervision of the DEC.
Nicoletti said, that in addition to remediating the TCE contamination, the DEC wants the methane gas escaping from the dump to be mitigated. Nicoletti said that the Proposed Closing Plan would address (subject to DEC approval) both a capping plan to close the landfill portion of the dump where ash from refuse is buried some fifty years is buried, to mitigate the TCE and methane gas emissions. Nicoletti did not explain what forms the capping might take, though he did go into detail in the work session last Thursday, saying it might consist of a 35 acre “impervious surface.” Mr. Roach and Ms. Lecouna Monday evening expressed hopes that that surface could be turned into a park.
Mayor plays down “millions” in future spending.
The Mayor at the outset of the hearing assured the television viewing audience the city had been working with the DEC and that the reports of millions being spent were inaccurate, that only $250,000 was going to be authorized to come up with a plan.
At the close of the questioning by the Council, the Mayor said he was pleased the city was moving towards of resolution of this problem in consort and cooperation with the Department of Evironmental Conservation
Techincally, the contamination had been ignored for 23 years, with the city conducting DEC- directed test monitorings that resulted in a DEC order to close the dump
Five years ago the DEC told the city it was in violation of a Department of Environmental Conservation order to close the city composting operation and stepped in to force the city to monitor the TriChloral Ethylene contamination because it was leaking into the Mamaroneck River which runs through the dump. The city stopped the composting, cleaned up the compost area, and asked the DEC for permission to resume it. The DEC granted resumption of composting, while continuing to demand tests and measurements from the city.
Asked by WPCNR why if the city had known the TCE containment (a clean fluid) was there for 23 years, it had not moved to clean it up on its own, Nicoletti told WPCNR the Department of Environmental Conservation said it was not necessary. Nicoletti said “if I had suggested spending $8 to$10 Million back then, they would have said I was crazy.”
Nicoletti’s address to the Common Council did not disclose the precise size of the TCE contamination zone though he was asked that question by Councilman Dennis Power.
Previously in addressing the Council in a work session July 22, Nicoletti said the area was 15 feet under the ash and soil level and about 50 feet square (2,500 square feet). Tonight he said it was about one 55 gallon drum of liquid.Nicoletti said that underground radar had not revealed any drums in the TCE area and that the radar was unable to see down that far to where the TCE was.
The Council did not press Nicoletti on the TCE issue.
The Council did not ask him how much the city might ultimately have to pay to clean it up, and how the city might pay for it. The council also did not ask Mr. Nicoletti what effect the ongoing TCE contamination might have on the generation of city workers employed in the dump to date the last 23 years or more, or the surrounding neighborhood.
Councilpersons Malmud, Benjamin Boykin, and Milagros Lecouna all requested copies of Mr. Nicoletti’s preliminary proposed closing plan prior to DEC submission. The preliminary plan is due in three months according to Nicoletti. Mr. Roach also with a string of questions, got Mr. Nicoletti to expand on all the tasks and activities the Gedney dump does now, but Mr. Roach stopped short of asking Mr. Nicoletti whether all those acitivies would continue to be permitted in the dump, in addition to the composting the DEC decree allows now.
The Certiorari Matter
Notable reductions in assessments of well-known properties of the $196,000 in lowered assessments are $47,500 deducted from Fenway Golf Club (a venue for outgoing Mayor Delfino’s political fund raisers) assessed value of $125,000, dropping the club assessed value to $77,500; $62,000 deducted from 199-201 East Post Road’s assessment of $71,000 reducing that assessed value to $9,000; the 189 East Post Road assessment is lowered $70,000 from $105,600 to $70,000. The Inns of Court Properties (where Mulino’s Restaurant is located) received the largest assessment reduction ($78,450) in this month’s round of certioraris reducing its assessed value from $193,450 to $115,000.









