Hits: 0
WPCNR County Clarion-Ledger. September 11, 2006: Chairman of the County Board of Legislators, Bill Ryan, with his previous letter has shared exclusively with WPCNR this letter to the Common Council of the City of White Plains and Mayor Joseph Delfino, reportedly setting the record straight on the closing of The Coachman Hotel as a homeless shelter. Mayor Joseph Delfino had announced in another media, The White Plains Times, that the county was required to sell the shelter back to the city after fifteen years.
County Legislator Martin Rogowsky rejects Mayor Delfino’s understanding:
WESTCHESTER COUNTY BOARD OF LEGISLATORS
800 MICHAELIAN OFFICE BUILDING
148 MARTINE AVENUE
WHITE PLAINS, NEW YORK 10601
(914) 995-2834
FAX (914) 995-3884
rogowsky@westchesterlegislators.com
MARTIN L. ROGOWSKY
Legislator, 6th District
Majority Leader |
n
September 11, 2006
Hon. Joseph M. Delfino
City of White Plains
255 Main Street
White Plains, New York 10601
Hon. Glen Hockley
City of White Plains
255 Main Street
White Plains, New York 10601
Hon. Arnold Bernstein
City of White Plains
255 Main Street
White Plains, New York 10601
Re: The Coachman Family Center in White Plains
Dear Mayor Delfino and Councilmen Hockley and Bernstein:
Thank you for your letter of August 29th regarding the County Facility located on the site of the former Coachman Hotel (Coachman).
You seem to believe that Westchester County is under some obligation to sell the Coachman property to the City of White Plains next year. Frankly I am surprised that you harbor such an erroneous belief given the key role Mr. Delfino played in the County’s acquisition of the Coachman in 1993 when he and I served together on the Board of Legislators.
Your letter is wrong on several important facts. First, the 1993 legislation as my former colleague, Mr. Delfino, who was its prime sponsor should recall, enabled the County to acquire the Coachman for “general municipal purposes”. It contained absolutely no provision that the County sell the Coachman to the City of White Plains after 15 years or at any time for that matter. Nor did the legislation contain any provision limiting how long the County could operate the Coachman as a homeless shelter.
With respect to any 15-year limit on operation, the legislation only authorized the County Executive to enter into an intermunicipal agreement (IMA) with the City of White Plains where the County would agree not to operate the Coachman as homeless housing for more than 15 years.
Although the County Executive was authorized to enter into such an agreement, none was ever approved by the White Plains Common Council and Board of Legislators nor signed by the County Executive and the Mayor of White Plains. It does not exist. There is also absolutely no record of Mr. Delfino taking any action as County Legislator representing White Plains to insure that such an agreement was consummated. In short, he dropped the ball.
Moreover, you are (or should be) well aware that the County is under no obligation to sell the Coachman to the City of White Plains. As a matter of fact, on April 21, 1993, County Legislator Joe Delfino issued a joint press release with County Executive O’Rourke containing the elements of the proposed Coachman legislative package which stated clearly that the County “will retain ownership” of the Coachman.
As you know (or should know), the legislation enabling the County to acquire the Coachman was approved by the Board of Legislators at the meeting held on June 7, 1993. Both Mr. Delfino and I voted for this legislation. I mention this only because the copy of Mayor DelVecchio’s communication to the Common Council which you attached to your letter is part of the September 7, 1993 Minutes of the Common Council (it is also not a complete copy as the last page is missing). Since this is well after the County Board approved your legislation, it is obvious that the Mayor’s communication was more concerned with the composition of the Community Advisory Board than the already-enacted legislative package for the Coachman.
I am also mystified by your inclusion of the July 1989 Memorandum of Understanding among the County of Westchester, City of White Plains and WestH.E.L.P. Inc. Mr. Delfino, as a County Legislator and a former Councilman knows that the Common Council refused to grant WestH.E.L.P.’s application for a special permit and denied its site plan approval at the September 4, 1991 meeting. As such, the July 1989 Memorandum of Understanding was rendered inoperative. I certainly remember this clearly.
In fact, I am sure that Mr. Delfino as County Legislator received a copy of County Executive O’Rourke’s letter dated October 28, 1991 to Mayor DelVecchio and the Common Council stating categorically that the Common Council’s action on September 4, 1991, released the County from any obligation under the July 1989 Memorandum of Understanding. As a legislator at that time, I was certainly aware of this as were all the other legislators including Mr. Delfino.
Moreover, the legislative package that Mr. Delfino sponsored and got approved referred to the nonprofit agency Westhab, not WestH.E.L.P. These are two different entities involved in two different proposals separated by nearly four years. So, please pardon me if I am unable to determine why you would include an inoperative Memorandum of Understanding as authority for your position when you sponsored legislation which so clearly contradicted it.
Your assertion that the “turnover of the Coachman is now at hand” is clearly wrong. Your assumptions regarding it are contradicted by Mr. Delfino’s past actions as a County Legislator. Your letter of August 29, 2006, like the July 1989 Memorandum of Understanding that you use to support it, is totally inoperative.
Finally, relative to the legislation now before the County Board to build affordable senior housing, if you would like assurances that this building will not be used to house the families from the Coachman, I suggest you read that Legislation, as I have. The assurance is also contained in the lease agreement.
As Majority Leader, I look forward to working co-operatively with the members of the Common Council and Mayor Delfino to bring this County-sponsored senior citizen affordable housing proposal to fruition.
Very truly yours,
Martin Rogowsky
Majority Leader
cc: Members of the White Plains Common Council