Hits: 0
WPCNR SCHOOL DAYS. By John F. Bailey September 18, 2006: Former School Board member Sarina Russell addressed the Board of Education last Monday evening and drew attention to the Board very quietly softening the standards of the School District Athletic and Co-Currcular Pledge.
Sarina Russell Criticises the Board of Education for watering down the District Co-Curricular Pledge, Monday evening, September 11. Photo, WPCNR News.
In light of the arrest of a Horace Greeley Cross Country Star last week, being allowed to compete in a Cross Country match Saturday (and finishing second) after being arrested and charged with unlawfully dealing with a child (a teenager at the runner’s drinking party was hospitalized with alcohol poisoning), Ms. Russell’s remarks were precognizant.
The new White Plains pledge that athletes and participants in WPHS sports and extra-curricular activities is significant in what it now says will happen to students caught drinking underage, drugging, or breaking laws.
In 2005-2006, the code read: “Upon initial disclosure (Editor’s Note: not on conviction) the resulting action can be automatic suspension from participation for a period of time to be determined by White Plains High School Administration or the Superintendent of Schools.” B. A second offense can result in automatic suspension from participation for a period of one calendar year form the date of violation. C. a third offense can result in permanent suspension from all co-curricular participation..
Note: These standards of behavior are in effect both in and out of school, 24 hours/day.
A Quiet Change
This spring this code was under consideration by the district and original writings were attempting to make it tougher and spell out circumstances of punishment. However, over the summer, it was changed (in discussion with parents, coaches, administrators, stakeholders) to only include offenses committed while participating in school team or school group-sponsored activities, or committed on school grounds, giving the appearance of allowing students to go undisciplined for infractions like underage drinking, drug consumption that they commit on their own time. (Apparently, the Horace Greeley School District approach is being adapted.)
(WPCNR is not aware of when or how this was adapted, since the last time it was being discussed was in June, and it was not promulgated to the general public for comment to this reporter’s knowledge.)
Off Campus Behavior Not School Related Not covered.
No Automatic Suspension.
The new Pledge is a departure from the 2005-2006 code and would appear that WPHS students will not be considered for punishment for doing drugs, drinking underage, fighting and violent behavior as long as it is not committed on school grounds, or on school trips. A student involved in a criminal investigation for an offense in the community however will be subject to a school review and possible penalty. What constitutes a criminal investigation is not defined, such as does the investigation have to result in actual arrest and charges filed on the misbehaving student.
The new code eliminates the “automatic suspension” punishment regardless of conviction, and appears to expand the period of time between offense and when discipline will be administered, while setting a series of softer “punishments.” The pledge in the 2006-2007 Parent Information Handbook dealing with consequences reads:
“I also understand that any violation of this pledge found after a proper investigation by school authorities will result in disciplinary action, including a warning, probation, a specified period of suspension and/or permanent suspension from the athletic and/or co-curricular activity. Also, I further understand that this process applies to a student who is the subject of a criminal investigation whether in school or in the community.”
The automatic suspension punishment for students committing such offenses outside of school trips and team activities, has been replaced with a mandatory referral to a district counselor for the offending student(s):
“I understand that I am expected to conduct myself both in school and in the community in a manner which demonstrates personal integrity and positive reflects on me and the District. If I am involved in an incident in the community which involves drug, alcohol or violent behavior, I understand I will be referred to a district counselor.”
Accountability Softened.
Judging from the way the pledge reads now, the fate of a White Plains athlete, a member of a school civic club who held a drinking party (as the Horace Greeley Cross Country student did last week), and was caught would suffer no penalty, and not even be investigated by the school district.
Perhaps referral to a counselor will be made, however the pledge does not say it is mandatory for the student recommended to a District counselor to see the counselor.
The new White Plains pledge does not spell out the grounds for suspension, and even states that the offending student may be given, in this order, a warning, probation, suspension. This appears to indicate the students misbehaving on school grounds, trips and school-related functions face little to worry about. Nowhere does it say in the pledge that the student offense will be put on the student’s permanent record.
Russell Raps the Board’s Knuckles.
Addressing the Board of Education last Monday night, Ms. Russell, a former BOE member, was appalled about the ambiguity of the new document and that it appears to say the district will only discipline students who violate the conditions of the pledge on school grounds, events or trips.
She told the Board of Education in certain terms: “It doesn’t do the job,” she said. “ It’s a cover your backside document not meant to be a punishment for children who do things they’re not supposed to do. It doesn’t send the right message. This document does not make me proud and I am angry that I have to sign something I don’t believe in.”
The Board of Education did not comment.
Reading the two pledges together, it appears the White Plains City School District is taking the Horace Greeley School District approach to student drinking parties and other offenses as long as it does not happen where the school district is in charge.
In the last three years, White Plains athletes and students found drinking on student trips and off-campus have received brief suspensions from participation, but have been allowed to remain on teams and in their activities, completing their seasons. Punishments for the offending students were hard to find out about except by “word of mouth.”
The school district settled a multi-million damage suit stemming from a Highlands attack on a student. The amount was not disclosed by the plaintiff’s lawyer, LeRoy Wilson, Jr. who confirmed the settlement to WPCNR. The School District attempted to cover up the assault of the male student by other students on the Highlands campus, and did not report it to the police. The resulting law suit brought by the parent of the victim for not being informed of what had happened was settled.
Meanwhile Up in Chappaqua
The Horace Greeley School District has not disciplined the football team members allegedly involved in the party in Chappaqua hosted by the charged Cross Country runner. Media reports indicate the football team members at the Cross Country star’s party will not be suspended either.
It is interesting to note that the Horace Greeley student who hostessed the drinking party and was charged with unlawfully dealing with a child, told reporters after her Cross Country match the Saturday following the party, that “everything’s been blown out of proportion.”
Reading the two pledges together, it appears the White Plains City School District is taking the Horace Greeley School District approach to student drinking parties and other offenses as long as it does not happen where the school district is in charge.
The two Co-Curricular documents follow in their entirety:
2005-2006 Student Code of Conduct Participation in Co-Curricular and Athletic Programs:
As a candidate for participation in co-curricular programs at White Plains High School, it is our hope that you will take advantage of the school’s numerous opportunities. It is very important that the student and parents/guardians read and understand the essential policies involved relative to participation. We view it as an honor and a privilege to represent White Plains High School as a member of a school sports team or student activity and thus, by accepting this honor, the student must accept the responsibilities that accompany it. These regulations have been established for the benefit of those who participate as representatives of our school in a variety of teams and clubs.
Each member must do the following to maintain eligibility to participate in co-curricular activities:
- Abide by the rules and regulation as specified by the District, the school and for athletes, the New York State Public High Schools Athletic Association.
- Abide by all club activity rules as specified by the club advisor and the Student Activities Coordinator, and for athletes, all team and training rules as specified by the coach and Athletic Director.
- Comply with academic eligibility requirements as established by White Plains High School
- Demonstrate good citizenship and appropriate behavior at all times as a representative of the school and community.
- Use transportation provided by the school traveling to and from all events. (Exception: advanced Transportation Release Form is available in Student Activities or Athletic Office.
The following actions will be taken when a student is found in possession of controlled substances, weapons, or is using or selling tobacco (excluding non-athletes), alcohol (except as part of a religious ceremony), marijuana, concaine, steroids, or any other controlled substance:
- Upon initial disclosure, the resulting action can be automatic suspension from participation for a period of time to be determined by White Plains High School Administration.
- A second offense can result in automatic suspension from participation for a period of one calendar year from the date of violation.
- A third offense can result in permanent suspension from all co-curricular participation.
NOTE: These standards of behavior are in effect both in and out of school, including 24 hours/day.
Due process review shall be afforded to all students, and an investigation of circumstances will be completed in a timely fashion. ANY VIOLATION OF THE ABOVE REQUIREMENTS WILL RESULT IN APPROPRIATE ACTION TAKEN BY THE PRINCIPAL, THE ATHLETIC DIRECTOR, THE STUDENT ACTIVITIES COORDINATOR AND ADMINISTRATIVE DESIGNEE DEPENDING ON THE SERIOUS NESS OF THE SITUATION AND THE FINDINGS OF THE INVESTIGATION THE ADMINSTRATION RESERVES THE RIGHT TO EXCEED OR REDUCE THE EXTENT OF THE DISCIPLINARY ACTION TO BE TAKEN.
(Parent and athlete are expected and required to sign and return the pledge)
The 2006-2007 ATHLETIC AND CO-CURRICULAR PLEDGE
The athletic and co-curricular activities at the Middle School and High School are integral parts of the overall educational program of the White Plains City School District. Participation in these activities is a privilege granted to students who maintain scholarship and citizenship within the rules and regulations of the District. The District believes that it is imperative that parents and the school district work together to set high expectations for student behavior both on and off campus.
The District expects that I will uphold the high standards of academic eligibility and abide by the rules specified by my coach/advisor. As a participant in an athletic and/or co-curricular activity, I will comply with all the provisions of the District’s Code of Conduct, and I pledge as follows:
- I will not possess, consume, be under the influence of, and/or distribute alcohol, tobacco and/or unlawful drugs, such as marijuana, cocaine or other controlled substances on school grounds or at school-sponsored events and trips.
- I will not engage in hazing, harassment, fighting, theft, vandalism or violent conduct on school grounds or at school-sponsored events and trips.
- I will not possess, consume and/or distribute performance-enhancing drugs or steroids at any time.
I also understand that any violation of this pledge found after a proper investigation by school authorities will result in disciplinary action, including a warning, probation, a specified period of suspension and/or permanent suspension from the athletic and/or co-curricular activity. Also, I further understand that this process applies to a student who is the subject of a criminal investigation whether in school or in the community.
I understand that I am expected to conduct myself both in school and in the community in a manner which demonstrates personal integrity and positively reflects on me and the District. If I am involved in an incident in the community which involves drug, alcohol or violent behavior, I understand I will be referred to a district counselor.
I have read the above and accept responsibility for my actions under this pledge
(Parent and student are expected to sign the pledge)