Hits: 0
WPCNR PRESS TENT. By John F. Bailey. May 5, 2004: Well, we’ve just finished a St. Pauli Girl brew at the Lookout Grill, overlooking the foothills of the Catskills in the distance, and we’re ready to tackle the brutal back nine of Westchester County’s newest golf course, Hudson Hills. Let’s go pick up our satellite-equipped golf cart and head to the 10th Tee. (To view the WPCNR Play of the Front Nine, see previous story.)
TENTH TEE. Hudson Hills. In an earlier article, WPCNR took you on a round on the Front Nine, now we’re heading home. Links Aficionados should note that the holes of Hudson Hills do not have names, but as a reporter, I have invented names for the holes to give them cache. Grab your clubs and head with us to the 10th , on an WPCNR virtual round at Hudson Hills, where all the tee shots are dead solid perfect, all the approaches up and down, and every putt “in the hole.”Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
Lost Valley. 10th Hole Par 5
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The golfer starts his long trek home on Lost Valley, yet another blind tee shot, a macho man’s hole demanding a 250 yard fade drive for eagle to clear the cart path (not visible on the right) and land into the second fairway. You’ll get lots of roll because the hole is downhill to the right down in the valley.
This is a blind tee shot with the green lying 250 yards from the cart path 300 yards diagonally from the wall of trees on your right. Your shot must carry with precision over the cart path to have a clear shot at making the green in 2 for bird.
The driver-challenged golfer may choose to lay up in the middle of the first fairway in front of the tee.
The second fairway is no White House Lawn, there is a rock creek crossing the fairway and the diminutive green is guarded by traps left and right and water deep right if you hit your approach fat.
10th Green, Looking back to Tee.
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
Lost Valley plays 521 yards from the black, 491, 452, and 413 from the green, blue, and gold tees. The green is beveled making for a tricky putt from front and there’s tendency to fly the small green and land on the 11th tee, or for a prevailing west wind to knock down your shot.
Pine Glen. 11th Hole. Par 3
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
An innocent looking hole giving you a false sense of relief coming off the challenges of the 10th. But, don’t let it fool you. The green is like the infamous postage stamp at Troon, but slightly larger, and not much apron between the back of the green and the pinetrees. Your shot has to carry a precise 190 yards and bite that carpet. Too strong and you’re in the pines. Green is relatively flat. A birdie opportunity. As the weather gets warmer the green will get faster and demand more caution on the part of the birdie hunter.
Pine Glen is 200 yards from the Black; 174 from the Greens, 151 from the Blues, and 120 from the Golds.
The Tower. 12th Hole. Par 4
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The 12th hole leads you back to the summit. Your tee shot should be aimed for the below right of the Tower seen on the horizon. The green is up the hill and to the right, demanding the ability to hit cleanly off about a 45 degree angle uphill lie.
12th Green: The green is narrow and hourglass shapped, sloping up hill and then down with a swale in the middle (not a good thing). Watch the grass bunker on the left with your approach. Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The Tower plays 435 from the black, 400, 362, and 313 yards.
Westward Ho. 13th Hole. Par 4
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The thirteenth hole is one of the most beautiful on the course and does not demand precision off the tee. The green is curled into the copse of trees on the upper left of the crooked fairway. The leftside bunker is 205 yards from the green, offering an inviting target to go for the up and down.
13th Green: Your approach though demands elegance and touch because you have to thread your 8-er or 9-er into the deep throated green that again is beveled. Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
Westward Ho plays down hill left with a very manageable 474 yards with a lot of roll. 424,380, and 337 from the Green, Blue, and Gold Tees.
THE GRAVEYARD. 14th Hole. Par 3
This hole’s name was coined by one of the golfers WPCNR interviewed, so called because the tee is right along side a 19th century cemetery whose silent stones observe your tee shot. It can be a graveyard for your round, too. Don’t the “Graveyard Gallery” scare you.
This 187 yard par 3 carries over a gulch, to a broad triangular green with two traps. You have to be straight. Graveyard Gallery is at your left. Again the copse of trees surrounding the hole will drop your shot dead when you hit into the west wind, while a North-north east wind will drift your shot left into a very nasty rough.
Hudson Crest. 15th Hole. Par 5
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
Holes 15 through 18 challenge your final leg with a Par 5 and three Par 4s.
Fifteen is a Big Time Hitter’s delight and a duffer’s nightmare. Here is a chance to show and use your power if you hit it straight. This is an uphill climb, the longest hole on the course from any of its four tees, it runs straight up hill but relatively free of pitfalls (unless of course, you slice or hook).
Here you’re looking up the hill to the green. The hole demands a carry of 250 yards to clear the scrub in the middle of the fairway Once you drive past the “scrub” in the middle of the fairway, you are 245 yards from the center of the green.
Hudson Crest’s green is guarded by a trap to catch the weak approach, which will roll back if you do not clear the crest. There is a forgiving apron surrounding the green, which is beveled to cup and hold your approach, but a “hot” low approach will shoot right through if you’re going for the green in 3. Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
Hudson Crest plays 568 from the Black, 532, 502 and 464, respectively from the Green, Blue and Gold tees.
Big Sky Country. 16th Hole. Par 4
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The most scenic of the Par 4s, Big Sky Country is welcome relief from the trek up 15, presenting an inviting birdie target. Plenty of room for your drive. The only panoramic fairway on the course.
Beware the two traps on the right. Big Sky Country plays 407 yards from the Black, 375, 351, and 324 from the Green, Blue and Gold tees.
Stairway to Heaven. 17th Hole. Par 4
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The hole on this 458 yarder is tucked away on a notch on the upper center right where the cart path leads. The skinny green is slightly to the right of the white sandtrap speck, and to the left of the cartpath. The fairway gradually then steeply rises up to the hole, which is guarded again by a trap and mogul like hills to the left of the crested green. It is 142 yards to the green from where the cartpath appears on upper right. Again the green is elongated beveled and tricky to putt. The “Stairway” plays 458, 393,348, and 316.
River Ridge 18th Hole. Par 4
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
WPCNR’s round finishes with a walk up 18 which with its classic clubhouse is reminiscent of Riviera Country Club in Los Angeles. The finishing hole is forgiving, and delivers breathtaking views west to the Palisades and mountains across the Hudson. You cannot quite see the Hudson River but it is there.
Walking the Ridge.
Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The fairway leaves no margin for error, hooks and slices will make the sayonara hole not very pleasant. A trap right in the landing area awaits, and two traps left of the green menace your second shot.
18th Green: A Demanding Approach to an uphill lie green. Photo by WPCNR CourseCam
The course is relatively short for tournament play, County Executive Andy Spano told WPCNR Sports, but he hoped the course could be used for championships of some kind.
The course design was by Mark Mungeam of Cornish, Silva and Mungeam, Inc., and runs 7,000 yards.
Cornish, Silva and Mungeam have created Stow Acres in Stow, Massachusetts, a GOLF DIGEST top 75 public course, Shaker Hills in Harvard, Massachusetts which was named Runner-Up by GOLF DIGEST as The Best New Public Course to Open in 1992, The Captains Course, selected by GOLF DIGEST as the Best Public Course to open in the USA in 1985 and currently ranked in the Top 25 Public Courses in America by GOLF DIGEST. They also created Cyprian Keyes Golf Club, selected by GOLF DIGEST as the Fifth Best New Affordable Public Courses for 1998.
Their renovation work includes Seminole Golf Club in North Palm Beach, Florida,
Olympia Fields Country Club in Chicago, site of the 1997 U.S. Senior Open and 2003 U.S. Open, The Broadmoor in Colorado in preparation for the 1995 U.S. Women’s Open, Jupiter Island in Florida, Lookout Mountain in Georgia and
Myopia Hunt Club in Massachusetts.
Be Careful out there.
WPCNR likes the front nine, because of the charming and challenging shotmaking required that challenges the skills and decision-making, self-analysis club selection required. You, sir, have to know your limitations and your capabilities.
I consider the back nine slightly anticlimactic. It could use more hazards, after the considerable creativity and use of terrain on the front nine.
The course is very fair, but requires some awfully long blasts of 250 yards or more off the tees to carry you over disaster trouble. The greens are very slow now without a lot of break, but golfers tell me that would change as the weather gets warmer.
Three of the final four holes are relentless challenges to hit the ball up hill, which you really get tired of along about the 18th tee. I would have liked to see some water hazards on the back nine. (How about some sandtraps crossing the short fairways? A humpback fairway? A shrub encrusted green? How about some mogul hills in the fairway or along the fairway? How about some tree placement around the greens? Could we have a moat around one green? Or at least one multi-tiered green on this entire course? (Sadistic, I know, but no less so than the back nine.)
Know Your Game, Baby.
You have to know how to hit off a sloped lie on this course. It is a narrow precise game called for on most holes, but forgiving in the fact that the rough is almost nonexistent, not like the jungle rough of all other county courses. The fairways are like most greens on other county courses. The greens on Hudson Hills do not appear extraordinarily difficult, but are relatively small, narrow and conducive to rolloffs. They offer you no margin if your approach is hot and low or your tv shot approach has no bite.
Amenities.
The clubhouse is small, and should have been built larger, which it was originally planned to be. It is advertised to accommodate 175 persons for a golf outing, but that would be a tight fit, in WPCNR’s opinion.
Here you have this beautiful spot, and it deserves a really good restaurant venue, with some major league cuisine found in any country club, where corporate types could entertain. This place is classy, but cozy. Though I love the pampering at curbside by the very hospitable staff, the clubhouse could have a little more style, style, sprawl and opulence, yet I love the wrap around deck, from which you can sip a foamy brew and watch approaches to the 18th green.
On the positive side the Lookout Grill, though it was not open when I was there, is tranquil, has great views, and is a cool place to sip a crisp cold, dewy chilled glass of brew after a round. I like what we have in the Lookout Grill, but it could have been so much better. Think the sprawl of the Ridgeway Golf Club lounge, for example.
Perhaps in the future the county would consider adding a separate sprawling restaurant interested in putting in that missing piece.
Play it. Enjoy it. Stay Home in Westchester.
The course is easily the best public course in the metropolitan area, Shinnecock Hills and Bethpage Black not withstanding.
WPCNR would be interested in golfers’ comments on the layout after they have played it.
Hudson Hills Scorecard and Souvenier Golf Cap. Photo by WPCNR CourseCam