Gedney Association: City Met In Secret with Common Council to Discuss Findings Statement. Disputes FASNY CLAIM OF “VICTORY”

Hits: 124

WPCNR WHITE PLAINS LAW JOURNAL. From the Gedney Association. June 19.2014:

The Gedney Association amplified its public statement by its President Terrence Guerriere Thursday, claiming for the first time the city administration exerted its influence on the Common Council on the implications of its Findings Statement on the Environmental Review of the French American School of New York plan to consolidate their three schools on the former Ridgeway Country Club.

The release alleges:  “The City admitted that they tried to circumvent the Open Meetings Law by having Council members meet with the City’s attorney behind closed doors to discuss the FASNY Environmental Finding and as a result the Court required the City to answer those secrecy claims asserted by the Gedney Association”

The complete statement reads:

The Gedney Association announced it was pleased the Supreme Court Decision of June 16, 2014 did not dismiss the Gedney Association Lawsuit—–contrary to the statements of FASNY. 

This Decision permits litigation against the City of White Plains to continue. The lawsuit stated various claims regarding the City’s review of the French American School of New York’s (FASNY) application to build a large regional school complex in the middle of the low-density Gedney Farms residential neighborhood. 

The Gedney Association asserted that the City violated requirements of the State Environmental Review Act (SEQRA) as well as the Open Meetings Law (OML) and other City rules and procedures in its review of the FASNY application. Speaking of the Supreme Court’s Decision Terence Guerriere, President of the Association noted

“We are pleased that the Court did not dismiss on the merits any of our claims regarding the ‘Environmental Findings’ of the Common Council, but only found that some were not ‘ripe’ for determination at this time—but these same claims will be ripe for determination when the Special Permit and Site Plan are decided.” 

President Guerriere also remarked that the Court rejected FASNY’s and the City’s assertion that the Gedney Association and Members did not have “standing” to sue.  Significantly, the Court did not dismiss the Open Meetings Law claim against the Common Council.

Gedney Association Attorney Dennis Lynch, of FEERICK LYNCH MACARTNEY, remarked “The City admitted that they tried to circumvent the Open Meetings Law by having Council members meet with the City’s attorney behind closed doors to discuss the FASNY Environmental Finding and as a result the Court required the City to answer those secrecy claims asserted by the Gedney Association”.

President. Guerriere remained confident all claims will be later decided in the residents’ favor noting, “The City’s violations of law made the environmental review process so defective that the Gedney Association and others were compelled to file this lawsuit”.  

 

Posted in Uncategorized

Republican Party Officially Introduces Guerriere as Their Candidate for Common Council Special Election

Hits: 109

WPCNR CAMPAIGN 2014. Special to WPCNR from the White Plains Republican Party. June 18, 2014 (EDITED):

As first reported by WPCNR Tuesday, the White Plains Republican Party  announced today that their candidate to run in the special election to serve the remainder of the unexpired term of Benjamin Boykin for the White Plains Common Council in November is Terence Guerriere.

Brian Maloney, Chairman of the White Plains Republican Party, heralded Terence’s qualifications and the need for a fresh voice on the Council:

“Terence Guerriere is a dedicated White Plains advocate, a community leader and a professional with an impressive resume and a proven record of meeting challenging issues.  We are excited to show the people of White Plains that there indeed is a strong voice for this great City’s hard working families and neighborhoods, that are presently being ignored.”

Mr. Guerriere, a Senior Vice President at Madison Commercial Real Estate Services, is a leader who has displayed keen insight in resolving complicated issues and has demonstrated a willingness to compromise and finding common ground in the most complex litigation. He is an experienced attorney and corporate executive.

Mr. Guerriere, in addition to the aforementioned experience, gained expertise as an attorney in private practice with McCarthy Fingar, LLP, was co-founder and General Counsel of Electronic Land Services. Inc. and a Managing Counsel for the National/Commercial Office of Old Republic National Title Insurance Company.

Guerriere is a graduate of Archbishop Stepinac High School, Williams College and earned his Juris Doctor from St. John’s University School of Law. Prior to his law career, Mr. Guerriere clerked for the Surrogate Court Judge of Nassau County, New York.

His previous career as a private school educator and administrator afforded Mr. Guerriere the skills to be an effective lecturer and coalition leader, and has spoken on the topics of legal ethics and complex issues of law and community planning.

Active in the  White Plains community, he has served on the White Plains Planning and Zoning Boards, including serving as Chairman, and currently is President of the Gedney Association, a local family advocacy and service organization. Mr. Guerriere is a co-founder of the Archbishop Stepinac High School Foundation.

 

Posted in Uncategorized

Court Denies All But One Claim in Gedney Association Suit Claiming City Did Not Conduct a Proper Review of the FASNY PROJECT. Gedney has 30 Days to Beef up Argument. Vows it Will Continue the Fight

Hits: 163

WPCNR WHITE PLAINS LAW JOURNAL. By John F. Bailey  June 17, 2014 UPDATED 11:10 P.M.:

On Monday, the New York State Supreme Court dismissed all but one complaint filed by the Gedney Association aimed at blocking FASNY’s proposed school project

Upon careful reading of the Judge’s papers this evening by WPCNR , Judge Joan Lefkowitz denied the City of White Plains motion to dismiss the Seventh Claim that accuses the Common Council of violating Public Officers Law.

This last surviving claim asks for an order enforcing the Open Meetings Law and a judgment declaring void the actions taken by the Common Council when they issed the Findings State.

The Judge’s decision  allows 30 days for the Gedney Association to resubmit their framing of this argument naming FASNY and allowing the Gedney Association to expand its argument on this Seventh remaining claim.  

Judge Lefkowitz writes, noting case law involving the Public Officers Law  allows that “the pleading is to be afforded a liberal construction. The facts are presumed to be true, the plaintiff is afforded the benefit of every favorable inference and the court is to determine only whether the facts as alleged fit within any cognizable theory.”

And, again, Judge Lefkowitz notes, citing another case law, that the court, “should not consider documents submitted by respondents in support of dismissal.”

According to the press release from the French American School of New York issued Tuesday afternoon, this lone remaining claim was “sparse and weak.”

In her June 16, 2014 New York State Supreme Court decision, the Hon. Joan B. Lefkowitz dismissed a number of claims challenging the City of White Plains Common Council’s environmental findings on the grounds that they were “nonjusticiable” and not appropriate for adjudication. There was one surviving claim  (the 7th)  that the court labeled as “sparse and weak.”

“This is a very important victory for the French-American School and the City of White Plains,” said Mischa Zabotin, Chairman of the Board of Trustees of FASNY.

Terence Guerriere, President of the Gedney Association gave WPCNR this statement Tuesday evening on Judge Lefkowitz’s ruling:

“I have not seen the FASNY press release so I cannot comment on it.
 
We are quite pleased with the decision of the Court.  The Court did not dismiss our litigation.  It was determined that that the environmental issues are not ripe at this time for determination by the Court. 
We will be able to assert the same causes of action when and if the Special Permit issue is decided in favor of FASNY.  Of course, had we not sued now, FASNY and the City would have argued when the Special Permit is challenged that we sued too late and should have sued before.  The Court also refused to dismiss the Open Meetings Law claim.
 
The result: the claims regarding the results of the environmental findings can be brought in full force and effect at a later date.  The Open Meetings Law challenge is alive and we continue the fight at this level.
In the FASNY press release Tuesday afternoon announcing the Judge’s ruling, Misha Zabotin commented:

“We have made significant improvements to our plan including a number of measures that will reduce the impact on traffic in the neighborhood by 50%, a reduction in total enrollment and increased buffers and landscaping around the campus. These improvements were the result of many months of technical study and are consistent with the SEQRA Findings that were supported by a 6-1 vote of the Common Council in December 2013.  We are pleased with the State Supreme Court’s decision and are ready to move forward.”

The lawsuit, filed earlier this year by members of the Gedney Association, claimed the White Plains Common Council did not properly review the environmental impacts of the school’s plan and that its positive findings in favor of the project violated the State Environmental Quality Review Act, or SEQRA.

“We are pleased the court ruled in our favor as there was never any legal grounds for these baseless claims,” said FASNY Attorney Michael Zarin. “The suit filed by the Gedney Association was baseless and a waste of everyone’s time, money and valuable resources, especially the taxpayers of White Plains.”

Posted in Uncategorized

Republicans Choose Terence Guerriere to Oppose Nadine Hunt-Robinson for Common Council Special Election

Hits: 174

20101012-terry

Terence Guerriere  (October, 2010) Tapped by White Plains Republican Party to Oppose Nadine Hunt-Robinson for the year remaining on former Councilman Boykin’s term.

WPCNR CAMPAIGN 2014. By John F. Bailey. June 17, 2014:  

 

Terence Guerriere, of Gedney Farms has been offered the opportunity to contend for the final year of former Councilman Benjamin Boykin’s council  term by the Republican Party leadership, beginning in January 2015..

This morning, speaking to WPCNR by phone, Mr. Guerriere confirmed he was offered the candidacy and has accepted it. He said the party had approached him at the end of last year after Mr. Boykin won election to the Westchester County Board of Legislators.

Guerriere, one of the leaders of the Gedney Association effort to convince the city not to approve the French American School of New York plan to build a 7-building school campus on the defunct Ridgeway Country Club, told WPCNR he has decided to run.

He said behind his decision to run again was the current political condition where the city government is not listening to the neighborhoods. He told WPCNR his campaign would forcus on repairing labor relations between the city and its unions; concentrate on filling up the empty storefronts along Mamaroneck Avenue and the downtown which he said has the most vacancies of rental space since before the recession began in 2008.

He has not picked his campaign manager yet but expects to receive input from former Councilman Larry Delgado and Terry Conroy.

The Guerriere candidacy may be contested by another former Republican Council candidate,Richard Cerulli, who may chose to run on the Independence Party line in November.

Meanwhile over on the other side of town, as I reported on WVOX Radio during the new John Marino Good Morning Westchester program,

IMG_1338[1]

Meanwhile, Charles Morgan, a Democratic City District Leader has begun collecting signatures to attempt a primary run to wrest the Democratic Party nomination from Nadine Hunt-Robinson..

At the JUNETEENTH PARADE Saturday,  CHARLES MORGAN was observed campaigning on the sidewalks as the parade marched down Mamaroneck collecting signatures in an effort to launch a primary bid to win the right to be the Democratic candidate in the Special Election, replacing Nadine Hunt-Robinson, presently filling the seat on an interim basis, the last four months, having been appointed to fill the seat until a special election can be held in the fall

Morgan told an organizer of the Juneteenth parade he is definitely shooting to primary Hunt-Robinson in September.

To recall the scenario resulting in Morgan’s primary effort, Democrat district leaders were upset when Hunt-Robinson was unexpectedly named to the Common Council Boykin vacancy because Hunt-Robinson had never been a district leader, and worse was not a registered Democrat, being a member of the Independence Party.

Leaders were also annoyed  that she was suggested to the Mayor and Common Council b the Ministerial Fellowship of White Plains which persuaded the Mayor that Mr. Boykin, former holder of the seat was an African-American and the black community needed to continue to have representation on the Common Council.

Previously, Nick Wolf, who is white, and a well-known district leader in the Democratic Party highly active in black community issues,  had been attending a number of council meetings over the summer and fall, in anticipation of being named to the seat to replace Mr. Boykin.

Ms. Hunt-robinson a wife of one of the ministers in the Ministerial Fellowship was suggested to the Mayor as an African-American to fill the “black seat” quote-unquote.

Thomas Caruso who is on the Democratic City Committee Nominating Committee challenged the Robinson nomination and lost by 1 District vote, but decided he would not primary Ms. Hunt-Robinson.

Mr. Morgan, though, also an African-American was not deterred. He was bothered by the notion that there was any seat that would be determined by the color of a person’s skin and would belong to any race, and has apparently decided to make a run in a primary to make a point.

 

Posted in Uncategorized

Group Riled by Astorino Plan to Review Playland Using Sustainable Playland Consultant

Hits: 151

WPCNR PLAYLAND GO-ROUND. From Save Playland. (EDITED) June 16, 2014:

Save Playland, the grassroots citizens effort that came together a year and half ago over concerns about a variety of threats to the long term survival of Playland Amusement Park, has stated their opposition to County Executive Rob Astorino’s recent announcement to begin a new “on the ground” study of Playland’s operations.

While Save Playland is relieved that the Sustainable Playland Inc. group (“SPI”) no longer has an Asset Management Agreement to run the beloved historic County park, and considers it a very positive development that the massive ‘Field Zone’ construction project has been taken off the table, this new turn raises deep concerns about the direction of County Executive Astorino’s true plans for Playland.

This new tactic to put off any decisions until after the Gubernatorial race is over will further delay any improvements to the park and may very well jeopardize any hope of getting a viable, experienced operator in place to turn things around.

It raises red flags that SPI is being allowed to remain on as an involved entity in any way whatsoever, least of all in being assigned oversight of the historic preservation and fund-raising duties for the park.

The new study proposed by the County Executive is highly objectionable because it is assigned to Dan Biederman, one of the architects of the original SPI plan. While well regarded in his field and clearly able to demonstrate impressive successes at Bryant Park in NYC and other locations, Mr. Biederman should not necessarily be expected to be an objective reviewer as he was part of the development team for SPI’s flawed plan, which has now been deemed unworkable. 

If further study truly needs to be done on the operations of Playland Amusement Park, an entity qualified specifically in the amusement park industry should be chosen to do it. In addition, it is being reported that the County Executive is paying Mr. Biederman $20k a month for his four month long “evaluation” bringing the fee to a total of $80k. This is enormous sum of money and raises the question of whether or not there was any bidding process for this consulting job.       

Save Playland is calling for the County Board of Legislators to continue their review of operators by meeting with the two remaining finalist applicants in the RFP process: Central Amusements and Standard Amusements.

With the same speedy and efficient method we saw the Labor Parks Planning & Housing Committee undertake this year in vetting SPI, the Legislators could quickly accomplish a review expounding on the vetting previously done on these two entities. This could move a plan into place going forward much sooner than the extended timeline County Executive Astorino has laid out at no further significant cost to taxpayers.

Now that the SPI plan has been withdrawn the County should proceed immediately to reach out to the other two finalist applicants before they withdraw their commitment to invest significant funding into Playland Park.

These two vendors – Central Amusements Inc. and Standard Amusements – have committed to investing millions of private sector dollars towards making Playland a success. They submitted their proposals after the 2010 RFP process was announced.

They may (understandably) have reached such a level of exasperation with the process at this point that they will now bow out never to return. These two remaining RFP respondents are prepared today to invest millions of dollars into the park and get things up and running in time for the 2015 Playland season; we cannot afford to squander this opportunity with further delays.

County Executive Astorino’s announcement this week should be rejected because:

  • The time for study is over. When carefully reviewed by the Board of Legislators, the SPI plan was shown to be fatally flawed.  We need to move on quickly to a solution that makes economic sense.  
  • SPI has not demonstrated any ability to be an effective advocate for Playland or the surrounding community and should have no further involvement in the Park’s future.
  • There are concerns about the announced ten-year contract with American Skating: Was there any bidding process for this contract and does it need BOL approval? Why did the CE choose to move forward with one of SPI’s chosen operators and not the other? (EDITOR’S NOTE: According to Chairman of Board of County Legislators Press spokesperson, Matt Richter, the American Skating contract is subject to approval by the Board of Legislators)
  •  The County has already paid $250k for a 260-page “Master Plan” for Playland drawn up by Bullock, Smith & Partners. In effect, little – if anything – has changed so, pragmatically speaking no new study is necessary. Hiring Mr. Biederman at this juncture to produce a new evaluation is redundant and an egregious waste of taxpayer money.
  • The goal of calling for a new study at this point is clearly to delay a decision until after Election Day and stop the tough analysis of SPI that the County Board of Legislators has undertaken in recent months.
  • The goal of this new plan put forth by County Executive Astorino appears to be to scare off the private sector investors with amusement park experience so that there’s no choice left but to default back to the inexperienced and under-funded SPI group at the end of the day. Sustainable Playland has clearly stated repeatedly that their “vision” has never included a successful Amusement Park at Playland. This is unacceptable.

Westchester County residents and the Board of Legislators should not accept these delay tactics and this plan to move the failed Playland process off the front pages until post-election season. It is time to choose a qualified amusement park operator before the clock and private sector dollars run out.

We are calling on the BOL to immediately circumvent these delay tactics, get back to the review process to finish vetting both Standard Amusements and Central Amusements, then move forward in a positive, constructive way to ensure a brighter future for this beloved Westchester County treasure.

Posted in Uncategorized

More Fallout on Sustainable Playland Departure

Hits: 143

WPCNR PLAYLAND GO-ROUND. Commentary from Stakeholders. June 14, 1014:

WPCNR continues to receive reaction on the fate of the Sustainable Playland proposal having been withdrawn this week and where it leaves the county attraction, Playland.

From Marissa Brett, of the Westchester County Association:

“We are deeply disappointed that after three years of discussions and planning, Westchester County and Sustainable Playland, Inc., have abandoned their agreement to redevelop Rye Playland. While no one party is to be blamed for letting the process flounder, certainly the process is at fault.

“Whether one agrees or not with Sustainable Playland’s proposed plans, it is apparent that the group invested considerable thought, time, effort, and money to rescue and resuscitate a money-losing county venture. Unfortunately, they had to work with multiple government entities, some with conflicting visions for the property, in developing their plans. In the end, Sustainable Playland ran out of patience and money for this project.

“Our concern is that this decision may jeopardize future projects between the private sector and the County. We have supported the use of Public-Private Partnerships to improve our County’s infrastructure and to monetize government assets. We need to encourage, and not discourage, more projects between the public and private sectors, such as North 60 at Grasslands in Valhalla, where Fareri Associates has a plan to develop 60 acres of County property for use by biotech companies, a key growth area for Westchester.

“Westchester needs a clear roadmap for developers to follow so there is less risk that important projects lose momentum and die. The Westchester County Association is committed to working with business and government to streamline the process, and we already are meeting with municipal leaders and sharing ideas. It is essential to upgrade our approach to development, and prevent others from spending millions of dollars that lead to nowhere.”

From County Legislator Ken Jenkins, (and Yonkers IDA Director):

“County Executive Rob Astorino seems to be doubling down on a failed approach that makes pre-mature pronouncements on a 10 year contract that will require a super-majority vote of the BOL and wastes taxpayers’ money to perform an analysis that the County Executive claims to have used in making his initial selection of Sustainable Playland.

“The time is now for the BOL, as the governing authority for Westchester County, to bring together the two remaining RFP respondents, Central Amusements and Standard Amusements and develop a lease for the management of Playland’s Amusement area using the framework of the 2010 Resolution adopted by the BOL regarding Playland. 

These last two remaining RFP respondents are prepared today to invest $25 million dollars into the amusement area and get things up and running in time for the 2015 Playland season. The BOL did this with the Children’s Museum with a unanimous vote then a unanimous override of County Executive Astorino’s veto.

“Friends of the Parks are well established group that supports all of Westchester and is concession vendor at Playland.  It will be interesting to see how the Astorino administration addresses the concerns of disparities that have come from organizations like the Central Park Conservancy. 

“I am hopeful my colleagues on the BOL will combine the remaining RFP respondents and develop a lease to operate the amusement area at Playland based on over 2 years of Committee hearings and public review.”

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized

Sustainable Playland President Defines Sustainable role Moving Forward

Hits: 136

WPCNR PLAYLAND GO-ROUND. From Sustainable Playland. June 13, 2014:

Kim Morque of Sustainable Playland has sent the following message to Sustainable Playland supporters today, defining the Playland role it hopes to have moving ahead after County Executive Robert Astorino announced this week, he was withdrawing the group’s Playland Improvement Plan

 

Dear Sustainable Playland Friends & Supporters:

On behalf of the Board of Trustees of Sustainable Playland Inc. (“SPI”), I want to thank you for your ongoing support, good-will and contributions over the years in our efforts to restore and transform Playland Park.As you may know, County Executive Rob Astorino has withdrawn the Playland Improvement Plan from consideration by the Board of Legislators. He has asked SPI to work with him and county lawmakers in a different but significant role as they continue their efforts in securing Playland’s future while working to implement elements of the original vision plan that are achievable in the current environment. 

The county executive this week announced a series of changes that included engaging Dan Biederman, one of SPI’s original consultants, and American Skating Entertainment Centers while also shifting SPI’s responsibilities. As part of these steps, SPI continues to have a significant role in improving the park and protecting its historic nature, amenities and attractions.

SPI will act as Playland’s chief private fundraiser, similar to what Friends of Westchester County Parks does for all of the county’s parks. We will also advocate for historic preservation of the park and reach out to residents around the county to promote their interests with respect to the future of Playland.

While SPI’s role is evolving, its vision and commitment have not changed. We remain committed to a restoration and preservation plan that recognizes the park’s unique and historic characteristics. SPI will continue being a not-for-profit organization comprised of volunteers that partner with county government to enhance and restore the park for future generations.

SPI is proud of the original plan and vision it presented for Playland Park. Our mission remains the same — to enhance, restore and preserve Playland Park for the 21st Century.  Thank you for your understanding and continued support. 

With Appreciation,

 Kim Morque

President, SPI Board of Trustees

PO Box 768

Rye, NY 10580

Posted in Uncategorized

Plane Crashes at SUNY PURCHASE Departing Westchester Airport. P ilot Sole Occupant Killed

Hits: 129

WPCNR NEWS BREAK. From Westchester OEM Reports. June 13, 2014 UPDATED 11:05 P.M. E.D.T.:

The Federal Aviation Administration reports a small Piper Malibu Meridian aircraft, originating from Westchester County Airport crashed one mile southwest of the airport near The SUNY Purchase College Campus.

There is one fatal injury to the pilot of the plane who was the only soul on board.

The pilot is identified by a spokesman for his family,  as Dr.  Richard Rockefeller, 65, a nephew of former Vice President Nelson A. Rockefeller, who also was governor of New York from 1959 to 1973. Richard Rockefeller ate dinner with his father, banker and philanthropist David Rockefeller, in Westchester to celebrate the family patriarch’s 99th birthday, a family spokesman said.

The spokesman described him as an experienced pilot whose death left the family in shock.

There are no additional injuries or fatalities reported. The college was not impacted by the crash.

The cause of the crash is still undetermined.

Posted in Uncategorized

FLASH! REPUBLICAN NOMINEE DEADLINE EXTENDED until MIDNIGHT SUNDAY. STILL TIME, BROTHER! WP GOP Chief gives Nominee ponderers for Common Council Special Election 48 hours to Think Decision Over.

Hits: 129

WPCNR BACKROOM BULLETIN. By John F. Bailey June 12, 2014  UPDATED  9:30 P.M E.D.T.:

With 3 hours to go until Thursday night’s midnight deadline, Brian Maloney, the head of the White Plains Republican Committee has extended his call this week for persons  to step forward and express their desire  to run  on the Republican Ticket in the fall Special Election for Common Council  through Sunday.

Moments ago Mr. Maloney issued this statement to WPCNR:

“because of people requesting to be considered, we have pushed our date before our final decision to Sunday night.”

Mr. Maloney, head of White Plains Republican Party posted an invitation on the White Plains Republican Party website on Sunday, June 8, saying, (after four months since Nadine Hunt-Robinson was appointed to former Councilman, now County Legislator, Benjamin Boykin’s seat on the Council), the GOP is still looking for a candidate to run for Common Council.

The following invitation was posted in a Click-Thru ad on Facebook June 8 and has been up for 4 days. No press release was sent to media announcing this “citywide candidate search,” nor was any news conference held announcing the unique availablity, tonight he has extended that deadline through midnight, Sunday night.
Get White Plains Back On Track!
The White Plains Republican City Committee announces its final call for candidates for the office of White Plains Common Council.
In order to be considered, a candidate need not be a Republican, simply a dedicated White Plains resident.
In order to be considered, a candidate must:
1) Be a registered voter and a resident of the City of White Plains for two years;
2) Be prepared to articulate the candidate’s vision of White Plains; and
3) Call 646-397-4675 or email: gopwhiteplains@gmail.com.
Council membership is a part time job that includes family healthcare, a salary and additional benefits. Candidates are also invited to submit any additional material they consider relevant to support their nomination.
Requests for consideration must be submitted by: June 12, 2014.
Brian G. Maloney,
Chairman.
This is a unique opportunity to assure a place on the ballot opposite Nadine Hunt-Robinson if you are a registered Democrat and wish to oppose her, without running a primary. Several disgruntled Democrats, one of whom expected to be appointed to the position, might take advantage of this opportunity, as well as councilpersons of the past, no longer on the council, and are itching to get back on.
You have 13 hours and 10 minutes to make that call.

 

Posted in Uncategorized

The Education Commissioner Comes to White Plains, Impresses: Reports Questions, Answers, Answer Justifications of 2014 Assessments Will Be Issued to NY School Districts In August. Says Educators More Positive About 2014 Test Experience

Hits: 0

IMG_1564[1]

Education Commissioner John King, standing far right, passionately explaining how the SED is taking fresh initiatives to help NY’s teachers teach the Common Core effectively and make it work. The scene: 701 Westchester Avenue, the BNY Mellon Board Room, White Plains, NY, USA

WPCNR SCHOOL DAYS. By John F. Bailey. June 11, 2014:

Actual Questions with answers and justifications of the answers that appeared in the 2014 New York State Assessments will be delivered to School Districts in August, the State Commissioner of Education told WPCNR Wednesday.

IMG_1567[2]

John King: proactive and passionate Wednesday morning about the need to sell the need for Common Core skills to the public.

Commissioner of Education for the State of New York John King delivered a request to the Business Council of Westchester Wednesday morning: He sought the business community help — for business leaders and community leaders to spread the word that the successful implementation of Common Core standards is needed to prepare NY children and turn out graduates with the skills the NY workplace needs.

He said districts needed to focus on what they are spending their budgets on to devote more funds they have to tuning Common Core teaching methods, commending  performances of school districts in Virginia and Maryland as  prudent spending models.

He spent a very cordial hour with the Business Council and experienced none of the rancor he received on his tours of school districts last year. He demonstrated a more involved and hands-on, “we’re going to fix this” attitude and expressed the confidence that as students become more familiar with Common Core-instilled skills, and the assessment test process the students  will improve test performance. He detailed one way the state is doing this:

He said the state is preparing videos of successful classrooms in action teaching the Common Core where school populations have been successful on the recent state tests and those videos will be sent to Principals to assist in preparing teachers to teach the Common Core standards successfully.

IMG_1570[1]

Meeting the Press: Mr. King spent a good 30 minutes with the media covering his White Plains stop. That’s Jerry McKinstry at left, and Marsha Gordon, President and CEO of the Business Council with Commissioner King.

In a post-meeting session for the media, I  asked Mr. King when copies of partial questions appearing on this year’s state assessment tests recently completed (demanded by teachers and advocated by the state legislator two months ago with the passing of the budget. King said a representative portion of actual questions (complete with answers and justifications for the answers from the 2014 ELA and Math assessments) would be furnished school districts across the state in August with 2014 state assessment results.

I asked him if these questions would be in time for districts to make curriculum results. He said, that did not matter because if the district is teaching the Common Core standards effectively, the students should have no problem with this year’s new tests:

“More test preparation doesn’t really work. You have to raise instruction levels to better outcomes.”

He said drilling on test questions was just teaching to the test, and that the legislature has limited the amount of time teachers can spend on giving students sample tests in the coming year.

Asked if Pearson the worldwide education publisher that prepares the assessments, had been given new suggestions and objectives how to formulate the 2015 assessments based on the test analysis so far, King said the Department of Education has not completed its analysis of the test results or drawn conclusions about the quality, effectivess and difficult of the questions.

When the SED analyses of how students responded to questions  were complete the SED impressions of what presumably caused wrong answers would be shared with the Pearson assessment test creators to incorporate in design of  2015 assessment test preparation.

He did not say whether the Stated Education Department would be seeking direct comment from teachers and principals and curriculum coordinators and passing them on — but he did indicate to me the SED is paying attention to comments about the test.

King said strides have been made this year on the 2014  assessments.

The state eliminated two  reading booklets used  for testing passages on the English Language Arts exam , which teachers said lead to confusion and frustration and in 2014 students had only one book to refer to. King said the tests were shortened. He told me in the news conference that commentary from educators on the 2014 tests indicated students handled the exams better and were not as stressed out.

IMG_1572[1]

John Ravitz, Executive Vice President and COO of the Business Council, explaining the skilled worker problem-solving gap the Westchester Business community has been experiencing the last 10 years.

John Ravitz, Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of the Business Council of Westchester told WPCNR in the news session with reporters that “everywhere” he goes business about Westchester County are concerned that new entrants into the workforce do not have the technical and problem-solving skills to analyze and make linear progressions of reasoning to orchestrate a project to completion, what he called the ability to take an assignment from “A-to-B-to-C-to-D.”

He was supportive of the Common Core for its objective to incorporate reading, writing and technical understanding. Asked if today’s I-Phone, Facebook, Instagram, connected twenty-something’s weren’t technically business ready, Ravitz told me, “They are very proficient technically when they operate amusements, but they do not possess an ability  to create a functional process that creates an answer or answers to a problem.”

Posted in Uncategorized