WPCNR VIEW FROM THE UPPER DECK. By Bull Allen October 20,2008: I have just taken a look at the new Yankee Stadium with the infield and outfield grass installed, viewed on the WFAN website from the air. The stadium confirms my worst fears.

The Big Ball Park, 1955
In attempting to duplicate the stadium, the architects have completely missed the towering effect of the former stadium, (above, 1955) with the antiseptic cantilever construction and setbacks of the upper decks. The sheer incline of the old stadium decks spread out all the action below you not way in front of you as the new upper decks will do. It also looks like the rakes of the many thousands of extra high priced lower level box seats may be flatter than they should be. The stadium seems lower in stature too.
Contrast this with Mr. Kaminsky’s photos on the WFAN website, You can see the new stadium view from the outfield at http://www.wfan.com/pages/3156752.php?imageGalleryXRefId=779910#imgGalleryImg
For a view from behind the plate go to http://www.wfan.com/pages/3156752.php?imageGalleryXRefId=779911#imgGalleryImg
Take a good look.
Instead, they have recreated Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles which is the oldest park in the major leagues next to Fenway and Wrigley Field.
Photographer Tom Kaminski’s photographs show the mezzanine and upper decks set quite a bit farther back. Instead of the upper decks’ edges being about 20 rows back from the edge of the field boxes as they were at the original Yankeee Stadium, they appear a good 40 rows back. Instead of the 60 degree rake of the old stadium, they appear to be 20 to 30 degree rakes. I think spectators are going to be way away from the action.

Note how the upper deck of the old stadium (circa 2003) poised you with the action at your feet — not way in the distance as it will be in the new stadium.
The field itself gives you a lot of left center, like the old ball park. But right field looks too shallow all the way to right center. The Yankees will need better arms than Matsui and Daimon in left next year. You have an approximation of new Comiskey Park in Chicago as a result. The outfield instead of the classic everyman melting pot bleachers of the old Big Ball Park, you have the monstrosity of the bleachers being split with what is going to be a restaurant in dead center field, with a big wrap around scoreboard. The wrap around scoreboard at the old ball park I never liked.
The replace of the copper frieze façade effect at the top of the top deck is lost because it is too far back. It will not dominate. You cannot even see it in the new photographs.
Overall this new stadium is a bad job, unimaginative, lacking grandeur. Of course, I am a crotchety old school baseball fan, so you may reject my views. However turning the new stadium into symmetricity, and allowing the tall scoreboard to block off views of the elevated loses a lot of the old stadium atmosphere, and creating a shooting gallery in right center in the outfield is not good in my opinion. Right field to right center has been given a Fenway look.
The new Yankee Stadium will be a fitting showcase for the team in decline that will inhabit it. A phoney, cheap imitation of baseball’s Westminster Abbey next door, which of course, they are going to tear down like the Barbarians did with ancient Rome.
Far be it from the city to keep the old stadium and tranform it into a New York Baseball Museum, which could actually still be used as a neighborhood ballpark, while preserving Yankee and Met, Dodger and Giant legacies with exhibits under the old stands, the old locker rooms — where the greats, Williams, Wynn, Dean, Grover Cleveland Alexander, Whitey, Mickey, Joe D., the Babe still haunt.
No, who would ever think of that — turning the old Stadium into a year-round tourism attraction for the South Bronx.
Go over to www.wfan.com and see what you think.




