Hits: 0
WPCNR KING KOMMENTS By William King. January 6, 2004: The proposed Main Street mixed-use condo-retail project I read about on your website from the Business Journal which appears more real with Martin Ginsburg being involved is just one of at least ten potential mid-to-high-rise development projects other than the City Center twin behemoths (I think that’s what the New York Times called them in Sunday’s Westchester section) proposed by Lou Cappelli … and there are certainly other potential development projects being formulated out
there that only a few people working on them know about.
In my last work session with the Council in December I threw out on the table, in vain I think, that the Council should keep in mind that other potential developments were out there that might be good for the City but, if the Council approved the full scale of Cappelli’s proposal, it could soak up all the traffic-carrying capacity of the downtown street network and make the rest of the downtown less appealing to other developers and their potential tenants. The mayor responded that a bird in the hand was better than 2 in the bush.
However, it seems there might be at least ten in the bush. The Common Council would be right to ask Planning Commissioner Sue Habel and the outside environmental review consultants, if they show up again, about this and it would be better if they would do this at a monthly televised meeting so the public could hear and chew on any meaningful answers.
Sue Habel once said when we were reviewing the traffic impacts of the City Center project before it was approved that the downtown street network could handle more residential and entertainment type uses, where traffic is more dispersed throughout the day and on weekends, but not much more office development because the downtown streets during weekday rush hours were already at or near capacity.
However, in the DEIS for 221 Main there is an argument made somewhere that the offices proposed at 221 Main were only one of three approved office projects (one of the other 2 was Gateway II by the Train Station over the parking lot at South Lex and Hamilton) and thus, since the other 2 were probably not going to happen, it was actually ok for the 221 Main mega project to move forward, that traffic would be less bad than if all 3 office
projects were to be built. You get all kinds of arguments like this in DEIS’s.
While I was on the Council there were presentations of six different development proposals that have not been built:
1. Barker and Church 10-12-story condo;
2. Church St. office condo bldg. between Main and
Hamilton;
3. A possible residential overbuild over and behind the stores
on the northeast corner of Mamaroneck and Post;
4. A mixed-use office/residential/retail project over the county-owned parking lot at
Court and Quaroppas behind the old Post Office Bldg. on Grand Street;
5. The Chelsea Piers-type of kids-focused project by Leon and Bonnie
Silverman between Mamaroneck and Court at Martine;
6. The 25-story or so residential/retail project on Main that Martin Ginsburg is now involved
with.
Four other potential redevelopment sites include:
1. the retail portion of the north side of Westchester Ave. between Bloomingdale Road
and North Broadway – some have mentioned in the past that the new
private parking garage built over the Stop & Shop parking lot was
partially built for such a possibility;
2. the White Plains Mall – possible mixed use overbuild;
3. possible overbuild combined with redevelopment (I would especially like to see) of the Verizon Building
between Main and Hamilton at MLK Blvd., aka Darth Vader’s Headquarters. I have mentioned this last possibility to both Bruce Berg of Lou Cappelli and to Verizon – they could do a sale of their property and
then lease back space in a new, taller, more attractive building or could be a co-owner of a new building and take greater advantage of their prime downtown location.
I just hate the appearance of the windowless Verizon Building – it’s like a black hole in the middle of
Downtown WP. In addition, I have heard directly from two other major developers who are interested in White Plains.
But development has to be controlled – it’s better for everybody, residents and developers (including Lou Cappelli). It’s also good to put the horses before the cart: get the State to fund the MLK/Grove St. extension project, get the I-287 project finished at least east to White Plains to drain off some of the cut-through traffic and get more
meaningful mass transit into White Plains (not just a downtown circulating trolley that is mostly for show), do something to inhibit traffic from cutting through Battle Hill and other surrounding neighborhoods … all virtually ignored by the 221 Main St. DEIS.
I remember once having coffee with Leon Silverman, who I knew from being at workshops together during the citizen involvement phase of the Comprehensive Plan in the mid-90’s, after I first came on the Council.
Leon talked about 10 to 20-story buildings along Mamaroneck Avenue between Maple and Main. I joked that wouldn’t we need the 7th Avenue Subway Line to come up from the West Side of Manhattan, where Leon grew
up, to White Plains to handle all the people? I was only half joking.
Downtown White Plains’ street network can only handle so much traffic and a good portion of what comes into the Downtown now cuts through the surrounding low density residential neighborhoods, something no resident
wants, so if you want to have development and redevelop some dead spots in the Downtown you can’t go crazy and you have to have a way for people to come and go other ways than by car.
The last thing I could add is that I have heard from life-long White Plains residents, including several residents of color, maybe not as old as the mayor but still life-long, who are not happy with what they see as Manhattanization. In the last few years I’ve heard phrases from those in favor of development to the max including “We’re not Mayberry,” “Halo Effect” and “Little Manhattan” repeated. I’m sure we’ll hear these again.
William King















