Hits: 0
WPCNR WHITE PLAINS LAW JOURNAL. By John F. Bailey. June 7, 2004: The attorney for Larry Delgado, former Councilman for the City of White Plains, announced to WPCNR Monday that Judge Francis Nicolai of the New York Supreme Court made a summary judgment decision Friday on the attorney general’s quo warranto action on Mr. Delgado’s behalf.
Binder said Judge Nicolai has ruled that Glen Hockley step down from the White Plains Common Council and Mr. Delgado be returned to his seat. Mr. Binder said the Attorney General is drawing up and order for the court to sign officially removing Mr. Hockley from the Common Council. He said, a stay, which applies in matters of government, does not apply to Mr. Hockley, since he is now a private citizen, a “usurper” who has been proven to be occupying Mr. Delgado’s seat illegally.

AT LONG LAST: After 31 Months of court wrangling and appeals, Judge Francis Nicolai has ruled that Larry Delgado was the real winner in the 2001 council election over Glen Hockley. The judge announced his decision Friday. Larry Delgado, center, is shown with Mayor Joseph Delfino on November 5, 2001, when Mr. Delgado thought that District 18 was going to bring him victory, instead it only produced 39 votes. He was shocked, impounded the voting machine in District 18, and the Delgado-Hockley election case was on. It would drag on for 31 months. Friday it entered another phase. The Attorney General will be drawing up a court order for the Supreme Court to sign officially ousting Glen Hockley from the Common Council shortly. Photo: WPCNR News Archive.

LARRY DELGADO: A Phantom no more. Photo: WPCNR News Archive
Binder said he felt “terrific” about the decision and that it “righted a wrong” that had been done to Mr. Delgado November 5, 2001 when a jammed voting machine in District 18 in White Plains cost Mr. Delgado 103 votes at least, which would have given him victory over Glen Hockley.
Because the machine jammed, Mr. Hockley was the apparent winner. Delgado contested the results behind lawyers Jeffrey Binder and John Ciampolli, and Judge Nicolai ruled in favor of a special election to be held in District 18 between Mr. Hockley and Mr. Delgado.
Mr. Hockley’s lawyer, Adam Bradley, appealed the decision to the Appellate Court in Brooklyn. That court ruled that the election Nicolai called for be held citywide, and not just in District 18.

GLEN HOCKLEY: Adovocating for Affordable Housing Units in the Cappelli Hotel May 26. Photo by WPCNR News
Hockley continued to contest the Nicolai Special Election ruling, taking it to the Court of Appeals in Albany on attorney Bradley’s contention that the courts did not have the authority under election law to decide elections.
The Court of Appeals found for Hockley and Bradley’s argument on March 14, 2002, ruling that Mr. Delgado’s only remedy was to initiate a quo warranto proceding through the Attorney General’s Office. Mr. Hockley was sworn in as councilman March 15, 2002, and has served 26 months in office as a councilman.

Adam Bradley: Took Judge Nicolai’s previous ruling to the Court of Appeals and won a reversal, setting the stage for the quo warranto action that has taken 24 months to happen. Bradley, now Assemblyman representing the 89th district has introduced legislation allowing judges to rule legally on election disputes. Photo by WPCNR News
Mr. Delgado did initiate a quo warranto proceeding through Attorney Joel Graber of the Attorney General’s office, and 103 affidavitts from voters in the 18th Election District in White Plains, swore they voted for Mr. Delgado. After presenting the evidence, the quo warranto action pressed for a summary judgment by Judge Nicolai on the matter.
Mr. Hockley and his attorney, Thomas Abinanti, asked the appellate court to throw out the quo warranto on grounds it has passed the stature of limitations, and for Judge Nicolai to recuse himself, even suggested that the Attorney General’s Office was “judge shopping.” The Appellate Court rejected those contentions.

Jeffrey Binder, shown this fall, preparing to vote in the Republican Primary at Ridgeway School, using one of the 50 year old voting machines, which a similar model jammed in 2001, costing Mr. Delgado 29 months off the Common Council. Photo: WPCNR News Archive.
Binder said Mr. Hockley could still appeal Judge Nicolai’s Friday ruling calling for the unseating of Hockley and the return of Delgado to the council as the “rightful winner,” however Binder said, in his opinion, a stay should not be granted in this case because Mr. Hockley is a private citizen “usurping the seat of the real winner of the election.”
Asked if Mr. Delgado was going to go after the approximately $70,000 in salary Mr. Hockley has been paid in his 29 months on the council that he has been there as “usurper,” Mr. Delgado’s attorney said “everything is on the table.”
Mr. Binder said he expected Mr. Delgado to be reseated in “a few days” as soon as the Attorney General fills out an order requesting the Supreme Court to do.